Gideon explained that the temporary federal work would end in summer and that he could earn wages afterward as a survey assistant or stock inspector. Clara wanted him to find work he respected, not merely labor that kept him near her. He said that whatever job he chose would include a promise not to disappear for weeks without telling her where he was going. She smiled and said she would make the same promise, though most of her journeys went no farther than the supply store. They laughed, discovering that a shared life could be planned one ordinary condition at a time.
The spring rose from the ground beside Nathan's grave, and Clara sometimes wondered whether it was fitting to marry another man under the tree where she had buried the first. The question troubled her until she spoke with the preacher who had conducted Nathan's funeral. He reminded her that graves were places of memory, not fences built to confine the living. Nathan's faithfulness to her had been part of their marriage, not a demand that she remain alone after his death. Clara left the conversation feeling that she had been granted permission, though the preacher insisted it had always been hers to give herself.
When Gideon proposed, he did so at the well on an evening when the creek ran full with spring runoff. He had brought Scout's collar out in his hand, not as a bargain or a reminder of what he had done, but because the promise attached to it had changed both their lives. He said he had come to the valley owing a debt to Nathan and had remained because he had learned to love the woman Nathan once loved. He did not ask to become master of the spring or savior of the household. He asked whether she would share a future with him as a partner who could sometimes be wrong and would need her to tell him so.
Clara laughed through tears and said she had never been shy about telling a man when he was wrong. Then she told him yes. She asked for time to finish the planting before the wedding and to tell Nathan's family in her own words. Gideon agreed without hesitation, placing the collar back in her hand. They stood together beside the well while the water continued its patient work beneath the stones, and for once neither was listening for approaching horses.
Their engagement was not kept secret. Clara told the Mercers, the Bells, and several other neighbors over the following weeks, and the news traveled through Sweetwater more quickly than a stagecoach. Some people remembered Gideon as the man who had faced twelve armed riders in the widow's yard, and they predicted a grand celebration. Clara intended no such thing. She wanted a small ceremony beneath the cottonwood, a meal shared with the people who had helped her keep the farm, and a day in which no one was made into a legend.
The request proved difficult for friends who wanted to show gratitude. Ada insisted on baking a cake, Ruth Bell offered flowers, and Philip Ward asked whether he could print a notice. Martin offered to repair the porch before guests arrived. Owen volunteered to carry the rings and immediately regretted it when the adults laughed. Gideon said he would handle the seating, then was firmly informed that his talent for arranging an arrest did not make him the proper person to decide where the preacher ought to stand.