Finch's hand trembled against the edge of the desk. He said land was not his business, which was true as far as jurisdiction went. Gideon told him that a threat of violence was his business and that a man who wanted the office should be willing to do that part. He did not threaten to remove the sheriff, an authority he no longer possessed. He warned that a documented refusal to investigate could become evidence in the review already underway, and asked Finch to put his position in writing if he meant to stand by it.
The sheriff looked toward a shelf where the town's few law books sat beneath a coat of dust. Finally he produced a sheet of paper and began taking notes while Gideon spoke. Gideon offered no praise for doing the minimum. When the statement was complete, he made Finch sign the date and agreed that both men would keep copies. Then he asked who employed the men who had last been seen cutting fence near the Whitfield boundary.
Finch answered that a foreman named Briggs Rusk worked for Crown V. Gideon knew the name from freight reports and old complaints in another county. Rusk had a reputation for settling disputes with his fists and for leaving little evidence afterward. One man at the saloon had recently bought cartridges for a .44 rifle, and Finch acknowledged that Rusk favored such a weapon. The sheriff admitted these facts only after Gideon had made clear that withholding them would be difficult to justify if the violence continued.
Gideon left the office and crossed the street to the saloon. Men who had been laughing over a card table looked up as he entered, measuring his coat, his gun belt, and the silence he carried. Rusk sat at the far end with his boots stretched toward the stove and a mug of coffee beside a glass of whiskey. He was thick through the shoulders, his nose bent from an old break, and one eyebrow divided by a pale scar.
Gideon ordered coffee. He made no accusation, asked no theatrical question, and waited while the bartender brought the cup. Then he looked down at the foreman's boots. A small square gap showed in the line of nails around the right heel. It was not enough to convict a man of anything, but it matched the detail Clara had drawn and gave Gideon a reason to watch how Rusk behaved when the subject arose.
Rusk noticed the scrutiny. He smiled and asked whether the stranger liked his boots. Gideon said they looked well traveled. The foreman suggested that strangers who stared at other men's feet sometimes ended up beneath them. Gideon finished his coffee and placed a coin on the bar, refusing the invitation to turn the room into a fight for men who wanted a spectacle.