Martin protested that Owen had insisted before either of them could stop him. Clara answered that the insistence mattered, but so did the adults who kept the journey as safe as they could. She knew people would tell the tale in town as if one boy had crossed the whole range alone and summoned a legendary gunman. The truth was less theatrical and more generous: a father, a trapper, a brave child, an old promise, and officials willing to perform their jobs had made it possible for her to remain standing in her own yard.
After Martin rode away, the afternoon settled over the spring. Gideon moved the chair from the porch back into its place against the wall. Clara gathered the cups and carried them inside, then paused because the house felt different with danger no longer waiting in every sound. She did not know whether to laugh or cry, and did neither for a while. Gideon followed her only when she asked if he would help carry water.
They worked until the shadows lengthened. The animals needed tending, the fence still had loose rails, and a meal had to be prepared regardless of arrests and warrants. At sunset Clara took a plate of bread and beans out to Gideon where he sat near the barn. He thanked her and asked if she had any objection to his staying another few days until the deputy marshal confirmed that the remaining riders had dispersed. Clara answered that she would be glad of the company.
That evening she told him something she had not been able to say when he arrived. She had been angry with him for giving her Scout and then riding away. Not because the dog had done anything wrong, but because loving another creature meant having another life that could be taken from her. Gideon listened and nodded, accepting the accusation as the truth of one part of her grief. He said he had chosen to leave because he feared imposing himself upon her, but he had not considered that the absence itself might become another burden.
Clara asked whether he would have stayed if she had requested it at the funeral. Gideon said he did not know. He might have mistaken the request for a momentary need and refused out of a misguided idea of respect. Clara considered the answer and said that people had a remarkable ability to call their own fear consideration for somebody else. The observation made him smile despite the sadness of the evening.
He told her about the deputy killed during his last investigation. He had not described the mistake to anyone in the valley before that night, and the words came awkwardly at first. The deputy had asked him to trust a witness who claimed a powerful trader was warning fugitives of impending arrests. Gideon delayed action because he wanted proof that would survive court, and the witness disappeared before that proof was gathered. The deputy died trying to reach the river camp, and Gideon carried the belief that he had mistaken caution for wisdom.