Owen asked whether the new arrangement would allow a thirsty stranger's horse to drink from the spring without signing a paper. Clara smiled and said a horse could not sign anything, and that no rule ought to make kindness impossible. The adults laughed, relieved to find that the plan could include generosity without depending on one person's memory. Gideon offered to draft a simple form that listed the regular users, the irrigation order, and how disputes would be resolved, leaving ordinary emergency use available whenever water could safely be shared.
The first thaw arrived with heavy mud that swallowed wagon wheels to the axle. Clara worked in the lower garden and found the rosebushes by the porch still alive beneath their winter covering. Nathan had planted them badly the first year, setting the roots too near the foundation until she made him move them, and the memory came to her with unexpected warmth. She realized she could recall the argument without feeling the familiar stab that every cheerful memory must end in loss. Grief had not diminished. It had changed enough to make room for pleasure.
Gideon returned from a week assisting Cole with the inquiry carrying a parcel of new tools purchased in Cheyenne. He had accepted temporary duties limited to interviewing witnesses and organizing records, with an agreement that he would not command deputies or become involved in the Whitfield intimidation case beyond giving testimony. The work suited him better than a return to the old life of endless pursuit. He said it had been difficult to trust other officers to finish tasks he began, but he was learning that a good investigation needed more than one capable man.
Clara welcomed him at the gate, where Scout used to wait. The empty space between the posts still hurt some mornings, but she noticed that the sight of Gideon's horse brought something besides sorrow now. He dismounted, looked at her without assuming he could embrace her, and asked whether she had missed the help with the fences. She answered that she had missed the company at supper. He smiled in a way she had never seen from him in town, unguarded and almost boyish.
Inside the parcel was a small brass plate for Scout's marker, stamped with the words He kept watch and the date of his death. Gideon explained that he had ordered it from a man who repaired saddles and engraved harness fittings. Clara touched the letters and said the wooden marker already served well. Gideon agreed, then admitted he wanted the dog's name to survive another hard winter. She thanked him and placed the plate beside Nathan's account book until they could fasten it to the post together.
In March, the small claimants gathered in the Whitfield barn while snowmelt still ran beneath the grass in narrow shining channels. Clara had cleared a table and set out paper, a ruler, and Nathan's old survey notes. Martin Mercer arrived with Ada and Owen; Joseph Bell brought his wife, Ruth; two