Over supper he explained what he had done in town. He was careful not to speak as if the arrival of a former marshal settled the matter. The sheriff had recorded the complaint; the land inquiry was advancing; a deputy marshal would arrive if the magistrate found grounds for a warrant. Rusk was a suspect, not a convicted man, and the boot print was a clue rather than a magical proof. Clara listened with gratitude for the precision, because she had lived too long among people who treated suspicion as certainty when it suited them.
She showed him Nathan's notebook, the sketch of the print, the jar holding the cartridge, and the copy of the threat. Gideon examined each without touching what he did not need to touch. He asked whether there had been a horse with a distinctive gait among the riders she heard, or a particular voice that stood out. Clara remembered a low laugh and the scrape of metal against the well's stone curb. When she repeated the laugh, he did not tell her whose it might be.
After supper they walked the lower fence with a lantern shielded against the wind. Gideon noted the places a rider could cross the stream and the strip of rough ground that would force horses to slow before entering the yard. Clara showed him the haystack remains and the point where the fence had been cut cleanly rather than broken by cattle. He listened when she explained why a gate on the southern side had been moved the previous year to protect a bank of willow roots. She knew the land's practical details better than anyone he could ask, and he treated her knowledge as the foundation of every plan.
When they returned, she asked whether he meant to fight the Crown V men. Gideon answered that he meant to prevent anyone from being hurt if prevention remained possible. He said that a man who trusted only his gun usually found himself using it when patience might have served better. Then he admitted that patience had its limits, and that he would not allow Rusk to enter her house with threats or force.
Clara told him that she did not want another person dead because of her land. Gideon answered that the responsibility for violence belonged first to those who chose it. She shook her head, not because she disagreed but because the graves beside the spring made that truth hard to live with. He did not insist she feel better merely because he could put the matter into words.