For several days afterward they were awkward around each other, smiling at ordinary questions and then looking away. Ada Mercer noticed immediately and did not mention it until Clara visited for flour. Then she asked whether Gideon had finally found the courage to say something sensible. Clara blushed and told her there was nothing to announce. Ada replied that announcements were overrated, but it was a relief to see a woman who had carried so much trouble look pleased by an ordinary morning.
Clara admitted that she was afraid of the town's judgment. Some people would call the affection too soon after Nathan's death, though more than a year had passed. Others would claim she had replaced her husband with the man who came to defend her property. Ada answered that the same people had been willing to judge her for refusing to sell the spring, for accepting help, and for insisting the law hear her complaint. A life built to satisfy them would be smaller than any cabin in the territory.
The advice did not remove every doubt, but it changed the questions Clara asked herself. Instead of wondering whether strangers would approve of Gideon, she considered whether he listened when she disagreed and whether he respected the work she had made her own. He did. She considered whether his attachment had grown from pity or guilt over Scout's death. It had begun in a promise, but it had become something warmer and more ordinary through months of shared work. She began to trust that distinction.
Gideon carried worries of his own. He was older, accustomed to solitude, and uncertain whether he could learn the habits of a household without trying to manage it as though it were a camp of men under his command. He did not know much about growing crops and had no desire to be admired as the great protector of a woman who had survived long before he returned. He feared that marriage might bring expectations neither of them had named. For once, he chose to speak rather than disappear until the fear passed.
They sat at the kitchen table one rainy evening with the lamps burning and discussed money, work, and land. Clara insisted that the farm remain her property regardless of whether they married. Gideon agreed and said that his savings could help repair the house if she wanted a written record of his contributions. She said they would keep separate accounts for the land and shared expenses, at least until they learned how the arrangement worked in practice. The conversation was not romantic in the way songs promised, but afterward both felt more secure about the possibility of a common future.