He told Nellie she could ask about Andrew whenever she liked, and he promised to answer what he knew. She asked whether Andrew would have liked her. Caleb considered the question. "He would have asked you a hundred things about Daisy," he said. "He loved horses, and he loved children who knew more than he did." Nellie smiled, then asked whether they could put the picture near the little tree. Caleb found a safe place on the mantel. For the first time since the war, he did not feel that keeping Andrew close required keeping the house quiet.
The guardianship hearing began after the new year. Mrs. Fitch's report emphasized that Caleb had provided consistent care, schooling, medical follow-up, and protection without restricting the child's ordinary friendships. It also described Ada's role and recommended that she be formally recognized as an additional trusted adult in the child's care. The judge questioned Caleb about his income and what he would do if drought made the ranch unprofitable. He answered that he could take seasonal repair work and that Nellie's estate would be administered separately, not used as an informal source of money for his farm.
Judge Bell asked a harder question. "What will you do when this child becomes older and disagrees with you?" Caleb looked toward Nellie, who had asked to remain in the room for this portion of the hearing. "I expect she will," he said. "I hope she will. We'll argue about whether she can ride farther than the creek, about schoolwork, about the proper time to go to bed. But disagreeing with me won't make her lose her place in my home." The judge waited a moment, then asked whether he could accept a decision that Nellie might one day choose to live somewhere else. Caleb said yes, though the thought hurt.
That answer mattered to Mrs. Fitch, who had seen guardianship cases in which adults used affection as another language for ownership. She asked Caleb whether he believed rescuing the child entitled him to decide her future. He answered no. "I believe it means I owe her a fair chance at a future," he said. "The court gets to decide whether I'm the person best able to provide it. And she deserves to be heard about where she feels safe." It was not a polished answer. Its plainness carried more weight than a speech would have.
Poole's counsel raised the question of Caleb's unmarried status and his rough financial circumstances. Ada testified that she had known Caleb for years, that he sought medical care when the child needed it, and that he followed routines without treating Nellie's fears as misbehavior. Dr. Price confirmed improvements in her health and weight. Miss Bennett submitted school records showing consistent attendance and progress. The judge also considered the possibility of a placement with Ada alone, then asked Nellie privately what she thought about the options. The girl said she loved Ada, but she wanted the ranch with Daisy, the crooked garden rows, and the man who asked before entering her room.