Caleb received the news without celebration. Fitch's account was useful, but what struck him most was that Poole's employment had operated on the same principle as his guardianship: people became expendable when they no longer served him. He asked Henry whether Fitch had somewhere to go after his hearing. The sheriff looked surprised. "He cut your fence." Caleb nodded. "He did. He'll owe for it. I'm asking if he has somewhere he can earn the money without being paid to do worse."
Henry mentioned that a railroad repair gang needed laborers, and Caleb said he would not object if the sheriff offered the information. He did not hire Fitch himself. Nellie deserved the security of knowing the man who had watched their house would not simply be invited inside. Caleb was discovering that mercy sometimes required distance as well as compassion.
Meanwhile, Poole's lawyers challenged the medical evidence. They asked Dr. Price whether some bruises might have come from falls, whether a child could misremember details, and whether he had witnessed the injuries being inflicted. The doctor answered each question narrowly. Yes, some individual marks might have other explanations. Yes, children could misremember dates. No, he had not personally observed the assaults. Then he explained that the pattern of injuries, the child's weight loss, and the consistent description of confinement were matters the court should assess together rather than in isolation.
At home, Nellie worried that the doctor's honest uncertainties would be used to call her a liar. Ada explained that an honest witness had to say what he knew and what he did not know. "A person who promises more than he can prove gives the other side a place to pry," she said. Caleb added that truth was not weakened by careful wording. "You told what happened," he said. "Other people are trying to find the things that can be checked. That's their work. You don't have to turn into a lawyer to make yourself worthy of believing."
Nellie asked whether someone might still believe Poole. Caleb admitted that somebody probably would. Her face went pale. "Then what good is telling?" He thought before answering. "Because believing isn't the same as having the power to decide. And because the more truth we put where it can be examined, the harder it becomes for one powerful man's story to be the only story anybody hears." She considered that without appearing comforted. Sometimes a truthful answer could only begin a conversation.
The county physician requested that Nellie return for a follow-up examination, and Caleb asked if she wanted Ada to accompany her instead of him. Nellie chose Ada and Mrs. Fitch. When they left, Caleb worked on a broken wagon wheel for hours, then realized he had put the wrong size spokes into one side. He pulled them out and began again. He could handle danger in the shape of a gun or a charging horse. The uncertainty of a child being examined while he could do nothing was a hardship he had never learned to name.