"Please... Don't Let Him Take Me Back!” the Little Girl Cried — Then the Cowboy Refused to Move

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Caleb learned of the letter when Mrs. Fitch asked him to explain the incident before it became a surprise in court. He told her the story plainly, including the part he regretted. The shove had protected nobody immediately, he admitted, and had made it easier for the officer to argue that the younger soldier was unstable. What changed the decision was that another sergeant brought blankets and a surgeon made a formal complaint. "I was right about the wounded men," Caleb said. "I was wrong to think I could settle it by losing my temper."

Mrs. Fitch asked whether the same impulse had appeared since Nellie entered his home. Caleb answered that he had wanted to strike Poole on the first day and several times afterward, but that he had not done so. "Because you were afraid of being arrested?" she asked. "That was part of it," Caleb said. "Mostly because the girl needs a place where adults can disagree without somebody getting hit." Mrs. Fitch wrote down his answer. It did not erase the old record, but it gave the court a more complete picture of the man than Voss's selective document could have done.

The past reached Nellie before the next hearing. A boy at school repeated a rumor that Caleb had killed a man in a bar fight and that the judge would send her away because he was dangerous. Nellie did not answer him. She went to Miss Bennett and asked whether the rumor was true. Clara, who knew only that Caleb had served in the army, said she would ask an adult with accurate information rather than repeat gossip. After school she brought Nellie to Caleb and explained what had been said.

Caleb knelt beside the porch step and told Nellie the truth in simple terms. He had hurt a man in anger long ago, he said, and had learned that protecting people did not require striking every person who frightened him. She looked at his hands. "Did you ever hurt a little girl?" she asked. "No," he said. "Never." She nodded, then asked whether he might still get angry. "Certainly," he answered. "What matters is what I choose to do when I am." She leaned against him and asked whether anger could be like a horse that needed a bridle. He told her that was a better explanation than most grown men managed.

The town's gossip also changed the way Caleb was treated. The feed merchant who once greeted him with jokes began speaking to him in stiff, abbreviated sentences. A widow who had praised his decision to help Nellie stopped inviting him to Sunday dinner after learning that Poole might call her as a witness. Caleb felt the retreat of ordinary friendship and understood why witnesses could be tempted to say less than they knew. It was easier to stay inside the accepted story. He was grateful for Ada, who remained at the table when the chairs around it became less crowded.

News in the same category

"Please... Don't Let Him Take Me Back!” the Little Girl Cried — Then the Cowboy Refused to Move

50 Part