He had been sixteen when he followed Andrew into uniform, young enough to think the world could be divided into good men and bad men by the color of a coat. The years since had taught him that cruelty often dressed itself in respectable clothes and carried papers with official seals. Poole's black coat was clean, his language precise, and he knew exactly which words would make a frightened child sound unreliable. Caleb recognized the maneuver before he knew the details.
Sheriff Henry Whitfield arrived with Poole several minutes later. He was a stout man with a silvering mustache and the unhappy expression of someone pulled away from a meal. Poole spoke first, describing a disturbed child, a meddlesome stranger, and an unlawful refusal to return a ward to her rightful home. Henry nodded as though the story matched something he expected to hear, then looked at Nellie. Her hand had not loosened from Caleb's trousers.
“Can you tell me what happened?” the sheriff asked. He bent slightly so she would not have to tilt her neck. The girl kept her eyes down and described the root cellar where Poole locked her after supper, the belt he used when she forgot a chore, and the night he left her there until morning with nothing but a candle stub. She spoke without embellishment, making each fact sound smaller than it was. The sheriff listened until she mentioned her mother, then glanced toward Poole's face.
“She's grieving,” Poole said. “She doesn't know what she's saying.”
“Those marks on her cheek?” Henry asked.
“She fell.”
“Every one of them?”
Poole's mouth tightened. “Are you accusing me of something, Sheriff?”
Henry's own daughter was eleven. She had been sick the previous winter, and he still remembered sitting beside her bed listening for each breath. The memory did not make him brave by nature, but it gave him somewhere to stand. He told Poole he would examine the guardianship papers, and that until he had done so Nellie would remain somewhere safe. Poole looked around at the gathering crowd, understanding the cost of an argument in front of witnesses, and left with a promise that this was not finished.
“Where will she stay?” Henry asked Caleb.
Caleb looked at Nellie rather than answering for her. “I've got a spare room and a woman who comes to help with the house. You'd be welcome if you wanted.”
“Will he know where I am?” she asked.
“Yes,” Caleb said. “I won't lie to you. But he'll know the sheriff knows where you are, too.”
Nellie considered that for a long time. Then she nodded.
They stopped at the general store for shoes and a loaf of bread. Caleb purchased a plain blue dress because the tear in hers was too large for an easy repair, and he asked the clerk to wrap the purchases separately so Nellie could carry something that belonged to her. The clerk avoided her bruised face, but she slipped a small peppermint into the parcel and did not charge for it. It was the first kindness Nellie had received that day without an instruction attached, and she held the candy carefully through the eight-mile ride.