"Please... Don't Let Him Take Me Back!” the Little Girl Cried — Then the Cowboy Refused to Move

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Rose described the creek at sunrise, the way Nellie used to chase grasshoppers between the fence posts, and the importance of learning accounts because a person could be cheated as easily with a pen as with a gun. She wrote that land was not important because it made anyone rich, but because it gave a family choices during hard years. Near the end she said she hoped Nellie would be brave without being made hard, and that the people who loved her would teach her when it was safe to rest. Caleb read the letter aloud only after Nellie asked. When he finished, she sat silently holding the paper against her chest.

The letter did not win a court case. It did something less measurable and perhaps as important. It returned her mother's voice to a conversation in which men had spent months discussing what the dead woman had owned. Nellie requested a small box to keep it in. Caleb found one in the workshop, sanded the rough edges, and fitted a simple latch. She painted the lid blue. On the inside, in careful letters, she wrote her mother's name and her own.

The week before the hearing brought the first real break in Poole's circle. Ellis Fitch, the thin rider who had accompanied him at the fair, walked into the sheriff's office with his hat in his hands and a bruise on one cheek. He admitted he had been hired to watch Caleb's ranch and report who visited it. He also admitted cutting the lower pasture fence, though he insisted he had done nothing to the wagon brake. Henry asked him why he had come forward. Fitch looked toward the window and said Poole had withheld his wages after telling him the work was not finished.

The sheriff was careful not to let the dispute over wages turn a confession into a bargaining performance. He warned Fitch that telling the truth now did not excuse the damage he had done, and that any promise of leniency would have to come from the proper authorities. Fitch said he understood. Then he told them about the second rider, Doran Pike, who had been paid to frighten Griggs into recanting. The broken bottle and shattered window were his work, Fitch said. He could identify the horse Doran rode and the stable where it had been kept that night.

Henry checked the story. The farrier remembered Doran buying a new saddle strap after the window incident, and the stable keeper confirmed the man had come in late. None of these facts proved who broke the glass, but together with Fitch's admission they justified more questions. The sheriff arrested Fitch for the fence damage, then sought an order to question Doran about the threats. Poole announced that he had never instructed anybody to break the law, a statement technically easier to make than it was to believe.

News in the same category

"Please... Don't Let Him Take Me Back!” the Little Girl Cried — Then the Cowboy Refused to Move

50 Part