evidence in the porch post and the testimony of his companions would be difficult to ignore. He eventually admitted that he had arrived armed to make the family afraid and that the nighttime attempt to remove the stakes had been planned. He continued to deny intending serious injury. The court had to decide what weight to give that denial.
Jacob testified with visible strain. He described his financial need and the steps by which Pruitt had moved from legitimate work to deliberate falsification. The questioning was uncomfortable. He was required to admit that he had signed a document he knew was inaccurate. Opposing counsel asked whether he had chosen to invent details to avoid punishment. Jacob answered that the original field book, payment records, and altered copy could be compared, and that his own liability did not make those measurements disappear. The explanation was not eloquent. It was precise, which mattered more.
Catherine's testimony was quieter. She described the first visit, the ribbon, the missing name of the supposed employer, the survey stakes, and the repeated attempts to frighten her family into leaving. She did not call Pruitt a monster. She said she had never met him before these events and knew only the decisions that had reached her gate. When asked why she had kept so many old receipts, she answered that a person who worked for twenty-two years to pay for land ought to be able to show how the payments were made. The courtroom laughed briefly, and even the judge's expression softened before the questioning continued.
Matthew was questioned about the night he fired at Voss. He explained where he stood, where the shot struck the porch, and why he believed he had to defend himself. He did not boast about his marksmanship. He spoke of the sound the bullet made striking wood near his face and of thinking that Catherine was alone somewhere beyond his sight. He was asked whether he had gone outside looking for a confrontation. He answered that he had remained at his own home and that he would have preferred every visitor to leave without a shot being fired.
The proceedings left the family tired. Ezra returned for important dates when he could be spared from work, and Alice sometimes accompanied him. Between hearings they gathered at the ranch and tried to speak about ordinary things. Sometimes the effort succeeded. At other times a casual sound or remembered remark pulled the conversation back toward the night of gunfire. Catherine learned that a legal victory could not instantly restore the careless ease with which she once walked out to the creek alone. Safety returned in increments: one peaceful morning, then a quiet week, then the first month in which nobody unexpected appeared at the gate.
The railroad consortium eventually sent a proper request to discuss the crossing. Bernard Hale arrived with two engineers and no armed escorts. He gave his full name before dismounting, produced credentials, and asked permission to look at the land. Catherine appreciated the difference without pretending it erased the earlier harm. She told him the family would consider a written proposal after the title issue was settled and after an engineer explained how the creek and cattle access would be protected. Hale accepted the conditions, though he warned that the company might choose another route if agreement proved too difficult.