Some answers were impossible to disprove without more evidence. Others were contradicted by the documents Avery preserved and the statements of the arrested riders. The case was not resolved in one dramatic conversation. Investigators compared dates, interviewed clerks, obtained copies of payments, and established which instructions passed between Pruitt and his agents. Pruitt repeatedly returned to the argument that he had sought a commercial agreement and that business disputes should not be transformed into criminal accusations. Rourke replied that business agreements did not require false maps or men sneaking around a barn after midnight.
Pruitt's wife, Margaret, came to visit him during the proceedings. She had known that his business was aggressive, and had enjoyed the comforts it provided, but had never asked how often his profits depended on frightening someone else. Now she faced neighbors who read the accusations aloud and daughters who wanted to know whether their father had really tried to take an old couple's home. She asked him to tell her the whole truth. He described a series of mistakes made by employees and ungrateful owners. Margaret listened until he mentioned the false survey and asked whether he knew it was wrong when he used it. His silence answered more than his explanation.
Their marriage did not collapse at once, and Margaret did not become a heroine merely by expressing disappointment. She had her own reckoning to make with the life they had built. She began paying closer attention to contracts and letters she had previously left unopened, and she insisted that their household expenses be reduced while the case continued. Pruitt regarded those decisions as humiliating. Margaret told him that humiliation was not the same as injustice. The phrase stayed with him, though whether it changed him was a question no one could answer quickly.
The county eventually heard testimony concerning the Hart crossing and the altered records. Lawyers argued over which communications represented negotiation, which constituted misrepresentation, and how far Pruitt's responsibility extended to Voss's conduct. Catherine did not attend every hearing. Her cattle still needed water, the roof still leaked near the back bedroom, and Matthew's joints did not become easier merely because a magistrate scheduled another session. Dean sent reports in letters that distinguished charges from findings, allegations from evidence, and temporary decisions from final judgments.
The prosecution of Voss proceeded on its own course. His gunshot wound healed slowly and left a stiffness he resented. He considered himself betrayed by Pruitt, though that did not prevent him from trying to blame the Harts for refusing the offer. His own counsel advised him that the physical