receipts, a drawing Matthew had made of the creek during the first spring they owned the place, certificates of purchase for the adjoining pasture, and invoices for work on the barn. There was also a letter from their son Ezra, written in the hurried hand he used whenever he worried that affection might sound sentimental.
Catherine spread the documents across the table while Matthew removed his gun belts and set them on a chair. The kitchen was warm with baking bread, and the familiar sight of her own handwriting on the receipts steadied her. They had not come by the ranch easily. They had bought it with money saved during the years Matthew worked as a trail hand and Catherine taught children to read in a settlement school where books were shared until the pages came loose. Their first winter there, the chimney smoked so badly they slept with a window open in freezing weather. Their third winter, a storm took the roof off half the barn, and a second mortgage had carried them through rebuilding.
Matthew bent over the creek sketch. The ford was marked near a grove of four cottonwoods. On the stranger's parchment, Catherine said, the water had been drawn farther west, as though the crossing belonged to land outside the section they held. Matthew thought it might be a mistake. Catherine reminded him that the man had covered that portion with his finger. “An honest error can be corrected,” she said. “A deliberate one must first be exposed.”
They decided to visit Hollis Dean, the county lawyer who had prepared their final purchase papers. The county seat lay forty miles away, too far to travel that afternoon and return before dark. Matthew wanted to ride at daybreak. Catherine told him to leave the second Colt at home, and he grumbled about how a man was expected to defend himself with half his accustomed equipment. She reminded him that a rifle leaning in a courtroom did not have the power of a clean title, and he admitted that she had never lost an argument merely by making it sound sensible.
Before breakfast the next morning she walked to the creek. Mist lay beneath the cottonwoods and the cattle stood knee-deep near the farther bank, drinking without concern for the future of the property on which they grazed. She knew that crossing intimately. As a young bride she had carried feed sacks over it while Matthew held the wagon team steady. Ezra had learned to swim there, badly at first, and once frightened her almost senseless by jumping from a bank deeper than he had judged. She was thinking of those memories when she saw a sharpened stake beyond the ford. The cut wood was pale, the fresh dirt undisturbed by weather, and beside it was the impression of a horse's hoof.