Matthew spent the morning repairing the loose rail damaged by Voss's horse. Catherine told him to leave it until the sheriff arrived. He said the wood had become unsafe and he would brace it without disturbing the bullet mark. They argued briefly, then agreed. It felt good to disagree about a piece of timber after a night in which the stakes had been life and death. They were still the same couple who had argued over hinges and roofing nails for decades. The ability to irritate each other over small things was one of the proofs that their life had not been stolen.
During the night of the attack Pruitt stayed in Fort Worth, dining with an acquaintance and speaking about a proposed investment in warehouse property. He had no way to know exactly when the riders reached Ash Creek. At one point he excused himself to ask a hotel porter whether a telegram had arrived. None had. He finished his meal and retired, certain that by morning the survey stakes would be gone and the Harts might finally be ready to accept money rather than trouble.
The first message came from a frightened rider who had escaped through the gate. It arrived after dawn and contained fewer words than Pruitt wanted. Voss had been shot, two men were held, and the old woman had seen the survey markers. Pruitt read the note standing beside his office window. He imagined every document he had handled now sitting on a sheriff's desk. Then he summoned a clerk and instructed him to gather correspondence relating to the Delgado transaction. He said the files were to be organized, but he watched the clerk's hands with the anxiety of a man who wants to destroy evidence and knows that giving the order may itself be remembered.
The clerk, a widower named Thomas Avery, had worked for Pruitt for seven years. He knew his employer's habits and the difference between ordinary irritation and fear. When told to remove certain letters from the file, he asked whether they should be archived. Pruitt answered that he would decide their destination later. Avery carried the papers into the rear office and quietly made copies of the most troubling correspondence before returning the originals. He did not yet know whom to trust with them. He knew only that his employer had begun acting as though a private business matter required concealment.
Avery had two daughters and no appetite for scandal. His first instinct was to keep his position and avoid becoming part of the dispute. Yet one letter described the Hart tract as a corridor to be delivered before title could be verified. Another directed Voss to make the owners understand that delays would have consequences beyond money. Avery had spent his career recording transactions he believed lawful. Now he held written evidence that some of the records were being shaped to create an appearance rather than describe a fact.