Alice and Ezra walked by the creek on their last evening. They spoke about marriage without deciding on a date. Ezra said he did not know whether he would ever return to the ranch permanently. Alice answered that a home could be built near parents without having to be the exact house in which a child had grown up. He asked what she wanted. She said a school where she could teach, a room with shelves for books, and a man who would listen when she said she had not yet finished speaking. Ezra promised nothing he could not prove by how he lived. They returned to the porch holding hands, and Catherine noticed without making the moment difficult for either of them.
When he left the next morning, Ezra carried a copy of the county report for his own records and an invitation to bring Alice for Christmas. He also carried a new understanding of the family's tin box. Its papers were not merely evidence against the Pruitts of the world. They were reminders that truth required maintenance, the way fences and roofs did, and that every generation inherited not only land but a duty to keep its records honest. He resolved to remember that if he ever signed a deed of his own.
Sheriff Rourke reached the ranch the following afternoon, tired, dusty, and unwilling to accept any account merely because the speaker seemed respectable. He examined the porch, the spent cartridges, the positions described by the prisoners, and the disturbed dirt near the barn. He spoke with Matthew and Catherine separately. Then he interviewed the three captives, including Voss, who insisted at first that he had arrived for a peaceful negotiation and fired only after being threatened.
Catherine brought out Voss's leather satchel, which had been removed during the seizure of the weapons and kept closed for the sheriff to inspect. Rourke opened it in Voss's presence. Inside lay the red-ribboned grant and the four-hundred-dollar offer. Dean arrived later that day, and Catherine watched the two men spread the documents beside the surveys at the kitchen table. The boundary on the purported ancient grant repeated the false position of the ford. It was not proof of every part of Pruitt's scheme, but it was proof that the grant and altered survey told the same useful lie.
The youngest rider agreed to make a statement. He described orders to remove the stakes and said the men had been promised that nobody would need to shoot. Voss cursed him, then fell silent when Rourke asked whether he understood the danger of allowing a frightened young accomplice to tell the only coherent account. Voss eventually admitted that Silas Pruitt had arranged the visit and promised payment when the property changed hands. He would not say Pruitt ordered him to shoot, and Rourke did not write that he had.