They Called Her a Fool for Approaching the Deadliest Horse — Then the Black Mare Followed Her

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Rusk's response became more direct. An unsigned letter arrived saying the bank would be interested to learn how the ranch spent money employing a widow who had no formal training. A second note suggested Samuel might hear troubling stories about his mother's accident unless Grant accepted a reasonable land arrangement. Miriam showed both notes to Whitcomb. He kept them as evidence of pressure but warned that without handwriting verification or a witness he could not attribute them to Rusk. Samuel was told only that adults were discussing business matters and that he should report any stranger who approached him.

That precaution proved necessary when the boy met a man outside the general store. The stranger offered him candy and asked whether the black mare was still at the ranch. Samuel remembered Miriam's warning and went inside to find the storekeeper. The stranger left before anybody reached the street. Samuel returned home frightened and furious with himself for not learning the man's name. Grant held him for a long time and said he had done exactly the right thing. For the first time, the father sounded more concerned with the child's judgment than with the information he might have gathered.

Miriam began to wonder whether Rusk wanted the horse removed because she could help identify something he feared. That suspicion was dangerous precisely because it made emotional sense. A horse could not testify about a crime. It could only react to familiar sounds or objects, and several innocent experiences might produce the same reaction. Yet the old saddle, the unauthorized survey, and Rusk's continuing interest formed a pattern that could no longer be dismissed as coincidence. She decided the next step belonged to the sheriff, not the corral.

Grant disagreed in one respect. He insisted the ranch should keep Nightbird where the men could see her, even if that meant postponing all training. Owen strengthened the gate latch and arranged for a lantern to burn near the barn through the night. Miriam asked for the mare to be moved into a safer enclosure closer to the house. Grant feared another sudden change would unsettle her. They compromised by opening a second pen and allowing Nightbird to choose whether to enter, using feed rather than force. By the third evening she slept near the barn, and the arrangement seemed ordinary enough to draw little comment.

On the last clear morning before a cold front, Miriam found an unfamiliar boot print beside the outer gate. She measured it with a piece of string and showed Owen, who said the tracks could belong to any freight worker visiting the barn. There was no sign of entry. She wrote the observation down anyway and did not tell Samuel. That evening Grant checked the locks himself. Neither man nor woman slept well, but dawn arrived without incident, and for a few hours they allowed themselves to believe the worst might remain confined to old evidence.

It did not. A stable hand discovered the outer gate open and the black mare missing just before first light. There were tracks from two shod horses heading north, and a length of cut rope hung from the post. Owen called for Grant before anyone disturbed the ground. Miriam saw the direction of the tracks and felt a cold certainty that did not amount to proof but was strong enough to set her moving. Whatever Rusk wanted from the ridge, the mare was being taken back toward the place where Lydia had died.

News in the same category

They Called Her a Fool for Approaching the Deadliest Horse — Then the Black Mare Followed Her

50 Part