They Called Her a Fool for Approaching the Deadliest Horse — Then the Black Mare Followed Her

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Remember everything you stopped looking at because grief gave you an easier answer.” He went pale with anger. “You have no right.”

“No,” Miriam said quietly. “But you asked Nightbird to carry the blame for three years. Maybe somebody should ask whether it belonged to her.” Grant ordered her out of the office. For two days, he barely spoke to her. On the third, he found Miriam in the tack room holding Lydia’s old saddle. “I told Owen to burn that,” he said. “He didn’t.” Miriam turned the saddle over. One stirrup leather had been replaced. The other was original and scarred near the buckle. “Look.” Grant came closer.

Along the underside of the saddle skirt was a deep diagonal cut. Not wear. A knife cut. Miriam pointed to the rigging strap. “If somebody sliced this almost through, it might hold until weight shifted hard.” Grant touched the cut with one finger. His face changed. “When we found her, the saddle was under Nightbird’s belly.” “Yes.” “I thought the cinch broke when she fell.” “Maybe it did.” He looked at Miriam. “Maybe somebody made sure it would.”

The foreman told him the man had already been turned away. Grant nodded, then surprised himself by asking whether the mare had eaten. Owen answered that she had and added that the new pen made the work safer for everyone. Grant walked away before the foreman could see the expression on his face. He was grateful Miriam had come to the ranch and angry that gratitude had made him reconsider so many settled judgments. He disliked what that anger revealed about him.

Rusk returned three days after receiving Grant's refusal. This time he brought two men whose presence he explained as ordinary assistance with the cattle inspection. One had a gray coat with metal buttons. The other carried a long measuring chain across his saddle. Miriam watched them from the kitchen window and recognized the way men exchanged glances when they did not wish to be observed making a plan. She asked Mrs. Bell whether she knew the strangers. The cook said the taller one had been seen around the ranch the year Lydia died.

Miriam did not repeat the claim immediately. Memory could be sharpened by suspicion until it cut through facts that had once been plain. She asked Mrs. Bell what the man had done. The cook remembered him waiting near the north gate and speaking with Lydia while Grant was away delivering cattle. She remembered because Lydia had afterward asked that all rope and wire left on the ridge be brought back to the barn. Mrs. Bell could not say why the request had seemed urgent. She only knew it had never been fulfilled.

News in the same category

They Called Her a Fool for Approaching the Deadliest Horse — Then the Black Mare Followed Her

50 Part