Caleb stopped near a weathered fence post. "I have thought about what you said at Christmas," he told her. "About seeing who we are on ordinary days." Evelyn waited. He said he knew his feelings for her had survived the quiet months as well as the frightened ones. He had come to enjoy the person she was when no one was watching, when she worked, rested, argued or simply read beside the lamp. He wanted to share his life with her and with Samuel. But he would not ask her to become the mother Rebecca had been or to remain in a position where her wages depended on pleasing him.
Evelyn looked down at the narrow path. "You have considered the difficulty," she said. Caleb answered that he had, but thinking about it was not the same as settling it. They could discuss her work, the ownership of what she had earned and the place she wished to have in decisions about the ranch. They could speak with Martha Caldwell about a written marriage settlement if she wanted protection for her own property. Evelyn looked up with a smile. "You make a proposal sound like an inventory of obligations." Caleb laughed. "Perhaps I am learning from a woman who reads every agreement before she signs it."
She took his hand. "I don't want a home where I'm always afraid that one disagreement will turn me into a servant again," she said. "I don't want a marriage arranged around your gratitude or my fear of leaving. I want to be able to stay because I choose to, and to speak freely even when you disagree." Caleb told her that was what he wanted, too. He did not promise they would never quarrel or misunderstand one another. He promised to work through those disagreements as a partner rather than a man issuing orders from the stable yard. Evelyn believed the promise because she had already seen him struggle to practice it.
The formal proposal came a week later, in the front room rather than beneath a dramatic sunset. Caleb had asked Walter to take Samuel riding for the afternoon and arranged a pot of tea himself, though he nearly boiled it dry while thinking about what he intended to say. Evelyn found him beside the table, his hat in his hands, and laughed at the resemblance to the day he had first tried to explain why she should stay. He took her hands and asked whether she would marry him in the spring, not to repair his past, not because she had saved his son, but because the life they had begun making together was the life he wished to continue.
Evelyn did not answer immediately. She thought of the freight wagon that had carried her to the ranch, the first supper eaten at the table, the window she had helped repair, the fire and the long road back to Cheyenne. She thought of Rebecca, whom she had never met, and Samuel,