silence could do no further harm once the case was closed. The letter did not ask forgiveness. It offered an account of hearing metal fall from the landing and of following the others down the stair after Evelyn lifted the bar. He said he would give the statement to Martha if it was still useful. Evelyn wrote back that truth did not become worthless merely because it arrived late.
The letter made her think about the people who never came out of the building. She had long kept their deaths as an accusation against herself, repeating that if she had climbed faster or found a different entrance, perhaps there would have been six rescued instead of four. Grace had told her more than once that a single woman could not defeat a burning building. Caleb said the same. Now, rereading the new witness's description of the smoke and the time already lost, she began to accept that the fire had placed limits upon everyone there. She could regret what was lost without treating regret as proof of failure.
Samuel noticed Evelyn sitting with the box open one afternoon. She invited him to sit beside her. He had seen the lock but not the child shoe, and asked whose it was. Evelyn told him it belonged to a little girl who survived the boarding-house fire. The mother had given it to her so she would remember the child lived, not only the people who died. Samuel held the shoe carefully and asked whether he could see the girl one day. Evelyn said the girl was older now, and if they visited Cheyenne together it might be possible. He smiled at the idea of meeting somebody whose life had once fit inside such a small shoe.
After he left, Evelyn considered how the tin box had changed meaning. For years it was the one place where her memory could not be contradicted by other people's certainty. She guarded it because she believed the objects were all that remained of her defense. Now the statements, newspaper correction and public hearing formed a larger record, imperfect but honest enough to carry beyond one person's room. She put the small shoe beside Grace's letter and the blackened lock, closed the lid and placed the box on the front-room shelf Samuel had made. It no longer needed to hide under a bed.
The wedding took place in May on a mild morning when the cottonwoods had begun to leaf and new grass covered the scars of last summer's burned fields. It was held at Stone Creek because a journey into town would have cost more than anyone wished to spend. Mrs. Alden brought flowers and arranged them in jars along the porch. Lucy prepared a modest cake, Walter borrowed chairs from two neighboring families and Peter polished the front-room lamp until the glass shone. Samuel washed Lucky twice, though the dog immediately found a patch of mud before the guests arrived.