at supper. He began to understand that the scars were not a curious detail from the past but part of how she arranged the present. If he asked a question, he worried she would disappear. If he did not, he feared she would think he had seen her and decided not to care.
Walter took the supply wagon to Cheyenne at the end of the week. He was meant to buy fencing staples, winter feed contracts and a replacement pump leather. Caleb asked him to inquire about grain prices and the possibility of renting a larger wagon for hay. Walter returned late, dirty and exhausted, with everything on the list and a story he had not known he was bringing. He told it first in the bunkhouse as men pulled off their boots. Then, finding their silence more alarming than their laughter, he went to Caleb's office.
"I didn't mean to stir trouble," he began. Caleb laid down the invoice. Walter said he had heard Evelyn's name mentioned at a livery counter, where two men were recalling a boarding-house fire three years earlier. The old Voss House on the east edge of Cheyenne had burned with people trapped on its upper floor. Newspapers had blamed a laundry worker with burned arms for carrying a candle near the stairway. Her name, Walter said, had been Evelyn Porter. The room seemed to lose air as he spoke.
Caleb asked what the men knew beyond the printed accusations. Walter admitted that they knew little. One had lived nearby and insisted two people died. Another had heard that the house's owner claimed the worker fled before investigators could question her. The men spoke confidently about what they believed, then disagreed about almost every particular. Walter had pressed them, but all they could tell him for certain was that the fire happened and Evelyn's name appeared in the papers.
"You should have come to me before telling the others," Caleb said. Walter looked ashamed. "I know. I was tired, and somebody asked about the town. It slipped out." Caleb could not undo the telling. He instructed Walter not to dismiss anyone and not to accuse Evelyn of anything until there were facts to support it. When Walter left, Caleb sat beside his desk in a long silence. He could picture Rebecca walking toward the barn with a lantern, and now another woman with burned arms moving through his kitchen. Fear made them seem connected, though his reason told him that resemblance proved nothing.
The next morning two hands refused Evelyn's breakfast. A younger rider named Frank claimed the newspaper story showed she was careless with fire, and Peter, anxious to stay agreeable with the others, left his untouched plate on the table. Samuel watched them and asked what was wrong with the biscuits. Frank said it was not about the biscuits. Caleb entered before the argument could grow, saw the uneaten food and told anyone unwilling to sit respectfully at the table to return to work. Frank left. Peter followed, looking at his boots.
Evelyn had heard enough. She continued stirring the oats, but her motions grew precise in a way Caleb had come to recognize as a defense. When Samuel tried to follow Frank outside, she told him gently to stay with her until he had finished eating. Caleb waited until the boy went