Margaret asked for the opportunity to answer with records. Owen's wages were documented, his testimony was corroborated by others, and he had been with the Dawsons on the night before Peter's fatal ride. The attorney still tried to suggest the young man had reason to resent the ranch. Margaret let him finish before producing a letter from Peter praising Owen's work and promising him a share of a successful cattle sale. The accusation did not disappear merely because it was cruel, but the documents exposed its weakness. Rebecca watched her mother defend a man who had little power to defend himself and understood why families in Dakota had once hired her.
Another witness arrived unexpectedly: the older gunman who had left Rusk's yard after recognizing Dakota Rowan. His name was Henry Beck, and he had once worked as a freight guard before taking jobs that paid better and asked fewer questions. He came to Cheyenne voluntarily after hearing that the investigator wanted accounts of Rusk's activities. Beck admitted that Rusk had paid the riders to intimidate Rebecca, not to witness a sale. He described instructions to make the offer sound like the only safe choice and confirmed that the youngest man had been told to display his pistol. He had heard Rusk speak of a planned arrangement with Sloane, although he had never met the investor personally.
Beck's testimony carried a cost. Other gunmen called him a liar and threatened to settle their differences when he returned to the trail. He told Margaret he had not come because of her reputation, though he knew she would hear the lie. He had come because the afternoon at Willow Bend reminded him of a woman he had failed to help years before. "I kept telling myself I was just riding along," he said. "Then one day I realized the families couldn't tell the difference between the man giving orders and the man holding a gun behind him." Margaret thanked him, not for his past, but for deciding what he would do now.
The magistrate authorized a search for Silas Trent and ordered the papers to be preserved pending further investigation. That should have felt like progress, but Rebecca returned to Willow Bend with the knowledge that the man most likely to know about Peter's death was still free. The ranch had survived the trip without her, yet the repaired fence had been cut again and a calf had gone missing. Walter Briggs said the remaining workers had done what they could. Rebecca paid the wages due, then sat alone for an hour with the accounts and wondered whether even a successful legal case could keep the ranch alive through winter.