Rebecca rode with her mother to the Miller property and watched the family study the clause. Mr. Miller became angry at first, as people often do when they have been fooled and need someone nearby to blame. He accused the women of trying to interfere with his contract. Margaret did not argue. She asked him to show her where the company had written its promised maximum charge. He looked down at the paper, searched it twice, and grew quiet. His wife, Caroline, said they had been assured the fee would never increase beyond what they paid for feed in an ordinary month.
"Then let the men who promised that put it in writing," Rebecca said. Mr. Miller looked at the door as though he expected Rusk to be waiting outside. Margaret suggested that every family bring its documents to the schoolhouse and compare them. A single rancher could be told a lie about market value; six ranchers looking at six different offers could see the pattern. Caroline agreed immediately. Thomas Dawson agreed only after his wife promised they would not sign anything else until a lawyer had read it. The meeting was set for Saturday evening.
Before then, Rebecca returned to the sheriff's office and demanded a written record of Hale's confession. He agreed to sign a statement admitting he had taken fifty dollars and disclosed information about Peter's saddle strap. He did not admit destroying the evidence because he insisted he had misplaced it. Margaret asked where it could have gone. Hale said his deputy had cleaned the evidence cabinet after a burst water pipe soaked the office. The deputy, a young man named James Foley, had been sent to a different district before Rebecca came asking questions. Margaret wrote his name down.
They found Foley at a livery outside town. He had quit the sheriff's office and now repaired harnesses for a living. At first he refused to speak when Rebecca asked about Peter's strap. He explained that he had a wife and a baby and could not afford trouble with men whose names appeared on land deeds across the county. Margaret bought a harness buckle he had repaired, paid the full price, and asked whether his fear would be smaller if she could promise his statement would reach a judge beyond Cutter's Notch. Foley looked at the money, then at Rebecca's face, and finally invited them behind the workshop.
Foley had seen Hale remove the strap from a shelf two days after Rusk visited. The sheriff told him to burn the spoiled leather with other damaged property. Foley refused. He carried it outside, but something about the clean cut troubled him, and he placed it in a wooden box behind the feed room instead. He had not known how to return it without accusing his employer of destroying evidence. Now he retrieved the box from beneath a bench, brushed dust from its lid, and held it out with both hands. Rebecca recognized the strap immediately.
Her breath caught when she touched it. This was the leather Peter had trusted with his weight and his life. For a moment it seemed obscene to treat it like a thing in a courtroom, because she remembered choosing the saddle with him years earlier and arguing over its cost. Margaret asked Foley to describe precisely where the strap had been kept and who had touched it after he took it. She wrote his answers down, had him sign the account, and asked Owen to verify the damage matched what he had seen. They placed the strap in a clean cloth and sealed the box without altering it.