The man in the brown coat gave his name as Eli Mercer, though Margaret doubted it was the one he had been born with. He claimed the horses had been sold to him by a ranch hand with no interest in paperwork. Owen recognized his voice and said so in front of the deputy. Mercer looked toward the road where the other prisoners waited, then asked to speak privately. Margaret refused to promise immunity, but told him that a truthful account might distinguish him from whoever had planned the theft. He glanced at Rebecca, then down at his boots, and admitted that Rusk had hired him to visit Willow Bend before Peter's death.
He had been ordered to inspect the tack and report which horses Peter favored. Mercer swore he had not been asked to cut anything and had not done so himself. According to him, a different man named Silas Trent had entered the barn later that night. Mercer said Trent sometimes worked as an enforcer for Frontier Basin and had a reputation for making accidents happen. He could not prove Trent touched the cinch. He had been paid to look away, not watch. The admission was incomplete and self-serving, but it provided a name no one at Willow Bend had heard before.
When the deputy asked where Trent could be found, Mercer said the man usually stayed in a room above the White Elk Saloon and rode a black horse with a cropped tail. He also claimed Rusk kept receipts in a leather portfolio that he delivered monthly to Cheyenne. Margaret recognized the importance of that detail. Individual threats could be denied; a trail of payments, if it existed, might tie the men to a company that insisted it knew nothing of coercion. She asked the deputy to record every word and let the territorial court decide what it meant.
Rebecca rode home with the horses but could not rid herself of the picture of a stranger handling Peter's saddle in the dark. The possibility that another man had made the cut brought no relief. It only widened the circle of those who might have watched her husband ride toward danger. At supper she asked Margaret whether she had ever spent years hunting a man who escaped justice. Her mother answered that she had spent years trying not to. "Then how can you sit here and eat?" Rebecca demanded. "Because if I stop eating, I become one more person you have to care for," Margaret said gently. "And because tomorrow we still have work."
The answer angered Rebecca. She accused her mother of being more interested in careful documents than in the man who had died. Margaret listened, then said Peter's death would not be honored by making another widow out of someone else's recklessness. "You think I don't want to find Trent and demand what he did?" she asked. "I do. But I have spent enough of my life confusing immediate action with useful action. I am asking you to trust that sometimes they are different." Rebecca walked out of the kitchen before she could answer something she would regret.