He died on a Tuesday morning while riding the north fence. At first everyone called it a terrible accident. His sorrel horse returned alone before noon with its saddle hanging crooked, and the two remaining hands rode out along the creek. They found Peter where the trail narrowed beside an outcrop of shale. A broken cinch strap dragged beneath the saddle, and stones along the trail bore the marks of a violent fall. By evening, the county doctor had confirmed that Peter's injuries were consistent with being thrown, and the sheriff had accepted that explanation without much curiosity.
Rebecca had been too stunned to question it. She sat beside Peter's body until the doctor persuaded her to come inside, then waited through three days of visitors who brought casseroles and spoke in hushed voices. She remembered nodding at things she could not recall hearing. She remembered making a list of wages due because Peter would have wanted his men paid. Most painfully, she remembered turning toward the back door at dusk, expecting to see his coat swinging from one shoulder, and finding only the empty hook beside the stove.
The first man to speak plainly about the strap was a young ranch hand named Owen Bell. He came to her two days after the funeral, hat twisting between his fingers, and showed her the damaged leather he had recovered from the saddle. The break was almost clean across the inner fibers, but its outer surface had not worn through. Someone familiar with tack could have weakened it with a sharp knife and made it appear sound when buckled. "I can't prove anybody did it," Owen told her. "But I've seen old cinches go bad. They don't generally look like this."
Rebecca took the strap to Sheriff Martin Hale in Cutter's Notch. Hale was a man in his late fifties with a weathered face and a habit of speaking as though every question placed another burden on his shoulders. He turned the leather over once, then suggested the buckle might have rubbed against a rock. Rebecca explained what Owen had said. Hale promised to keep the strap while he made inquiries. His promise sounded official enough that she allowed herself to believe it.
A week later, the first ranch hand quit. Another followed when the grain dealer refused to extend credit until the estate settled its accounts. Peter had planned a spring sale to cover expenses, and the ranch was not insolvent, but cash was scarce between cattle markets. Rebecca paid every man she could and accepted the departures without argument. She could not promise wages she did not yet have. By the beginning of the next month, only Owen and an older cook named Walter Briggs remained, along with a widowed neighbor who helped when she could.
That was when Clayton Rusk arrived for the first time. He rode a polished bay horse through the gate, tipped his hat, and introduced himself as an agent for Frontier Basin Development, a company with offices in Cheyenne. The company, he said, wished to make the difficult weeks ahead easier for a woman suddenly carrying too much responsibility. He produced an offer to buy the northern pasture at a price lower than Peter had refused the previous year. Rebecca read it twice and asked whether Rusk had mistaken a widow for a fool.