Saturday brought visitors. The schoolmaster arrived first to suggest a graceful withdrawal. The pastor followed with a speech about humility. A merchant whose store Rusk had threatened urged her to continue, then admitted he could not offer any protection if the contest ended badly. Clara listened to each man, sometimes politely and sometimes with a weariness she could barely hide. At last she went behind the house to the workbench, where her father's tools hung in their familiar places. There she found Thomas Pike waiting with a paper parcel in his hand. He had driven out without telling anyone, afraid that if he asked permission he would lose his nerve.
'I know what they're saying,' Thomas told her. 'About you losing.' He glanced at the rifle case. 'I don't know whether you can beat him. But I wanted you to know that not everyone is hoping you fail.' He offered the parcel. Inside was the cracked brass bell from the payroll wagon, the one whose ringing had accompanied every trip to the miners. Thomas had taken it off the wagon after the robbery because he could no longer bear the sound. 'Maybe you can use it for practice,' he said. Clara thanked him, then returned it gently. 'Keep it,' she said. 'If we're ever to get that road back, somebody needs to remember what it sounded like before Rusk came.'
She invited him to sit beneath the cottonwoods. Thomas had not told anyone how the robbery happened in full. He had said the men stopped the wagon, fired, and took the money. Now his voice shook as he described a fourth rider who stayed back behind the rocks, never showing his face. He remembered a silver glint by the rider's boot, a bright flash that did not belong to the three outlaws who had stepped into the road. Clara felt the hair lift along her arms. 'A spur?' she asked. Thomas stared at her. 'How did you know?' He had not been sure enough to tell the sheriff, and the sheriff had not seemed eager to hear more. Clara said nothing about the visitor from her childhood. Instead she asked Thomas to tell her everything he could remember about the horse, the direction of escape, and the sounds after the wagon stopped.
When Thomas rode away, Clara opened her father's journal. She had read the early pages often, following his calculations, the drawings of targets, and the small notes he had written after each journey. The final third remained unfamiliar. She had avoided it because each page felt like reopening a conversation he had never finished. Now she turned slowly through weather records and sketches of the northern ridge until she found several pages written in a smaller hand. One referred to the Alder Survey. Another listed three claims beside a watercourse marked only as North Canyon. Beside one name, Silas Kane, Gideon had drawn a narrow silver spur. The notation was not an explanation, but it was enough to tell Clara that the danger her father had feared was not over.
At dusk Edith found Clara sitting with the journal in her lap. She took one look at the page and closed the door behind her. 'You saw his name,' she said. Clara nodded. Her mother sat beside her, looking suddenly older than the woman who had stood in the street on Thursday.