A week later, the territorial marshal arrived with two deputies. Marshal Gabriel Ward was a middle-aged man with a limp from an old injury and a habit of listening longer than other officials expected. He reviewed the robbery reports, the contest testimony, and the threats against the Bells. He did not promise swift justice. He explained that Rusk could be held for the assault in town, but linking him to the payroll robbery required reliable identification and evidence of the stolen funds. The miner's strongbox had been found empty near Raven Wash, and Thomas could identify Rusk's voice but had never seen the fourth rider's face. Ward asked to meet Clara privately, then accepted Edith's insistence that her daughter would not be interviewed without her present.
'You have a reputation now,' Ward said. 'That can help you and hurt you. People who once wouldn't listen may believe every claim you make. Others will say any trouble that comes your way was invited by your pride.' Clara asked whether he believed Rusk had been paid to terrify the town. Ward answered that the pattern suggested it, but suspicion was not proof. He was waiting for records from a freight office in Kingman, where the stolen wages had allegedly been exchanged for notes. He advised Clara to keep the rifle at home and to let his deputies handle any threats. Edith nearly laughed at the advice, then caught herself. The marshal heard the humor anyway. 'I know,' he said. 'You've had reasons not to trust badges. My job is to give you better ones.'
The first real setback came from the stage company. Thomas was dismissed without wages, accused of negligence for losing the payroll. The manager claimed the firm had a policy against drivers surrendering funds without resistance. Thomas showed him the hole through his hat and asked whether he was expected to die for a wooden strongbox. The manager told him the decision was final. When Thomas returned to Mercy Crossing, he was humiliated enough that he avoided Clara for three days. She found him repairing a wagon behind the blacksmith shop and tried to offer practical help. He took her concern as pity, and they argued bitterly. 'You don't understand what it is to have people look at you as though your fear makes you less of a man,' he said. Clara looked at him for a long time. 'Thomas,' she answered, 'that is nearly all I've understood since Thursday.'
He apologized the next morning. They walked along the creek while he admitted that the robbery had changed him in ways he was ashamed to describe. He woke from dreams in which the shot came closer. He startled when horses stamped beside his bedroom. He disliked being alone, then found company unbearable. Clara told him she too had begun waking before dawn, hearing the contest shot in her mind and imagining the terrible different endings. Neither tried to tell the other that courage had made fear disappear. Their friendship became steadier because they could speak about the fear without competing over who had suffered more.