Dobbins came to the ranch three days later looking ill. He asked to speak with Edith alone. She refused and invited Clara to remain, explaining that her daughter helped manage the family accounts. The banker sat, stared at his hands, and admitted that Northern Passage Holdings had advanced funds to his bank during a period of serious losses. The loan carried conditions about acquiring land along the proposed route. Dobbins believed the investments would be profitable and had agreed to facilitate them. When doubts emerged about the titles, he tried to withdraw. Kane threatened to expose the bank's weakness and ruin everyone who had deposited money there. Dobbins had accelerated mortgages because he feared a run on the bank more than he feared injuring individual families.
'I told myself there would be compensation,' he said. 'That no one would lose everything.' Edith answered that several families already had. Dobbins looked up with red eyes. 'I know.' Clara asked whether he had knowingly accepted forged documents. He hesitated, then admitted he had suspected some signatures were false but had not investigated. He wanted protection if he testified. Edith did not promise forgiveness. She told him he could begin by returning every dollar wrongly demanded and giving the marshal the complete records. Dobbins said he would consider it. Clara watched him leave with a mixture of disgust and pity. She had expected a villain proud of his acts and found instead a frightened man who had harmed his neighbors while trying to avoid consequences for himself.
Ward was skeptical of Dobbins's sudden honesty. He brought the banker to Prescott under an agreement that anything offered in exchange for leniency would require the prosecutor's approval. Dobbins produced account books and letters showing that Kane had ordered the purchase of disputed land before title was established. Some letters referred to 'pressure' on reluctant owners and 'a lesson' for the town's stage company. There were also payments to Jeremiah Rusk, the contractor, and reimbursements for travel to Raven Wash near the date of the payroll robbery. The records brought the investigation closer to Kane, but no single document admitted an order to steal the payroll or attack the Bells. Kane's lawyer claimed the terminology referred to legal negotiations and ordinary security expenses. The case remained a contest between inferences and denials.
Clara found herself growing impatient with the law's careful pace. She had watched Rusk draw a pistol in front of hundreds of witnesses, yet he was still demanding a trial. She had seen signs of fraud, threats, and violence, yet Kane continued to give dinners at the hotel. One night she told Thomas that she understood why her father had been tempted to settle matters at gunpoint in North Canyon. Thomas considered her words before replying. 'You won your contest because everyone could see the target,' he said. 'This isn't a target you can put on a post. If you shoot at the wrong thing, the men who profit will go right on profiting.' Clara knew he was correct, which made it difficult to bear.