The route led to an old spring known locally as Soldier's Rest. It belonged to no company. Families traveling west had used it for generations, and ranchers along the valley depended upon it when the lower creek ran dry. Kane saw something more valuable. A road built through the canyon would give its owner control over a passage between two growing markets. If Kane could obtain the spring and the surrounding land, he could charge freight companies for water, lodging, and safe passage. He arranged for a series of claims to be recorded under different names, some genuine and others belonging to men who had never seen the territory. Lowell discovered inconsistencies in the surveys, but by then Kane had borrowed heavily against the promised future profits.
Gideon learned of the fraud after a winter storm trapped the surveying party in the canyon. A group of freight men arrived seeking water and found the spring enclosed behind Kane's newly erected fence. Kane demanded payment they could not produce. One of the men, weakened by fever, collapsed before Gideon managed to open the gate. Gideon carried him to shelter, but the man died before morning. The others survived. Kane blamed the storm, called the death unfortunate, and insisted the fence was lawful. Gideon asked Lowell to compare the claims with the original territorial records. The two men discovered that several signatures had been copied and that the spring's boundaries overlapped land expressly excluded from private sale.
'He wanted your father to keep quiet,' Edith said. 'Kane offered him shares in the road and a position overseeing the guards. Gideon refused. Then Kane reminded him that a man with a reputation for shooting could easily be accused of crimes committed by somebody else.' Clara listened to the dry grass rustling at their feet. Gideon had told stories about storms and difficult crossings, but never about this. Edith explained that Lowell had disappeared on the journey to bring evidence to a district office. His horse was found without him. The official report said he fell into a wash and drowned, though no body was recovered. Gideon believed Kane's hired men had taken him.
There was a confrontation in the canyon. Gideon tried to recover the survey book from Kane's camp, and one of the guards drew a pistol. Gideon shot the weapon from the man's hand, then held the others at a distance until the freight team escaped. It was the incident later retold as an impossible gunfight against a dozen men. In truth, Edith said, Gideon had been frightened for everyone present, especially the young guard who nearly lost a hand. Gideon left with several copied survey pages but not enough evidence to prove the full scheme. Kane moved north for a time, and a judge dismissed the disputed claims for lack of proper documentation. Yet some of Kane's associates still controlled parcels along the proposed road, and no one could say where Lowell's original book had gone.