every citizen could watch. Three shots each, at targets of his choosing. If she won, the money was hers. If she lost, she would polish his boots outside the Golden Spur saloon until he decided she had learned proper manners. The crowd laughed again. Clara agreed, though a tremor passed through her fingers when she shifted her father's rifle on her arm.
Nobody noticed the tremor except Edith. She had seen that same trembling once before, after her husband had carried their daughter home from a canyon where a horse had slipped on loose stone. Clara's fear was never evidence that she would stop. It was evidence that she understood the cost of going on. Edith stepped toward her, but the crowd had already swallowed the girl, congratulating itself on the entertainment to come. Rusk called for the bartender to keep track of wagers. Within an hour, people were betting twenty to one against the widow's daughter, and by evening someone had chalked her name on the saloon wall beneath the words MOST LIKELY TO CRY.
Three weeks before the challenge, Mercy Crossing had been a hard-working settlement with ordinary worries. The irrigation ditch needed repair. The stage road was losing traffic to a railway survey farther north. Two families were arguing about fence lines, the schoolhouse roof leaked, and Pastor Bellamy complained that more men attended the Saturday card games than the Sunday service. There had always been disputes, but people knew their neighbors, and the town had survived drought and sickness by refusing to leave one another entirely alone. That confidence had begun to erode when Rusk arrived with six armed riders and took rooms over the saloon.
The first incident seemed almost harmless. Rusk demanded the best table, drank without paying, and made the proprietor apologize for bringing him lukewarm coffee. Two days later, Crowley struck a ranch hand who refused to surrender a horse at half its value. Then a wagon carrying four thousand dollars in mining wages was intercepted near Raven Wash. The driver, Thomas Pike, came back pale and shaking, with a bullet hole through his hat and no money in the strongbox. He was nineteen, and until that day he had been proud of his work. Afterward he could barely guide a team of horses without hearing the shot over his left ear.
Sheriff Daniel Price had served the county for seven years. He was good at finding stolen cattle, settling domestic quarrels, and making young men sober up before they injured themselves. Rusk was different. The sheriff had ridden out to the Golden Spur with a warrant for a man wanted over the payroll robbery, then returned without serving it. He told the mayor he needed more deputies. He told the newspaper there had been a misunderstanding. That night he sent his wife and daughter to relatives in another county, a decision the town understood more clearly than his public explanations. His absence from the street on the day of the challenge was another kind of answer.