Their friendship deepened in these conversations. Thomas sometimes arrived with a sack of flour or a new bit of harness, pretending it was part of a trade. Clara learned to ask the price and pay it when she could, knowing he respected her more for refusing to turn care into dependence. They rode together on bright afternoons when the roads were safe, discussing places they wished to see. Thomas wanted to drive freight all the way to the coast. Clara wanted to stand in a city where nobody knew the story of the five hundred dollars. Both were careful with the idea of a shared future. They were young, and too much had happened for either to mistake gratitude for a promise of marriage.
One quiet Sunday, a year after Gideon's death, Edith invited Thomas to supper and served his favorite apple pie. The evening was easy until Thomas offered to repair the loose shutter on the kitchen window. Clara followed him outside with a hammer and ladder, teasing him that he had come to eat rather than work. As they stood beneath the stars, he asked whether she had ever regretted taking the bet. Clara thought for a moment. 'Sometimes I regret the danger I brought home,' she said. 'I don't regret that I refused to be laughed out of my own life.' Thomas nodded. Then, without a speech, he took her hand. Clara allowed it for a moment before Edith called from the doorway that the pie would be gone if they did not come inside.
The mystery of the anonymous survey page returned when Ruth Sloane sent a second letter. Her son had found a small chest of her brother's possessions beneath the printshop floor during repairs. Most papers were damaged by moisture, but a fragment of linen map survived, along with a page of a diary describing a stone arch, an abandoned camp, and a metal case wrapped in oilcloth. The diary suggested Martin Lowell had hidden his original field book inside the canyon rather than carry it out after being attacked. Ruth believed the anonymous page sent to Clara might have been copied by someone who had once seen Lowell's work. She enclosed a drawing of the stone arch, and Clara recognized the shape in her father's journal.
The new evidence persuaded Ward to organize a second search. This time he obtained additional deputies from the territory and planned the approach for a clear morning after the winter roads dried. Helen Avery would lead the survey work, while the Bells would identify the location from family records. The party included a court clerk to record any discovery and two independent witnesses from outside Mercy Crossing. Ward explained that finding a document in a hidden chest would not automatically prove every claim written on it. Its authenticity, history, and relationship to the recorded deeds would all have to be examined. Clara accepted the warning. She wanted a truth that would survive a courtroom, not another legend told around a saloon table.