Her second attempt involved a kitchen boy bound for the village. She asked him to carry a message to the postmaster, offering him sixpence from her own small purse. The boy agreed, but Cecily's newly appointed footman stopped him near the stable yard and demanded to see the envelope. By evening the letter lay on Cecily's writing table. Lydia was summoned to receive a warning about meddling in matters above her station.
'You may be fond of the children,' Cecily said, turning Lydia's letter between two fingers, 'but fondness is not authority. Your place is to perform what is required of you, not to instruct a lady on the management of a great house.'
'I only wished His Grace to know that the boys are unhappy,' Lydia replied.
'His Grace will know what I decide is worth telling him.' Cecily held the paper near the candle until its edge began to curl. 'You are fortunate I am inclined to be patient.'
Lydia watched the letter blacken in the flame. It was not the loss of the words that frightened her. She could write them again. It was the casual certainty with which Cecily destroyed the possibility of being contradicted.
The next days passed through a succession of small humiliations. Oliver was made to stand facing the wall because he laughed when Edmund made a rabbit shadow with his fingers. Edmund was told he must not cry for his mother, and when he could not stop, Cecily ordered his bedtime candle removed. Lydia restored it once the corridor was empty. She learned to move quietly, to anticipate Cecily's footsteps, and to make each secret act of kindness seem like part of an ordinary duty.
Mrs. Bell slipped into the nursery twice to ask whether the boys were well. Lydia answered truthfully, but the housekeeper had begun to look worn with fear. Mr. Talbot, who handled the estate's books, refused to discuss the matter, saying he would not jeopardize the duke's affairs over domestic differences. Lydia could not wholly despise them. She knew the cost of unemployment in winter. Yet each refusal left her carrying more of the burden herself.
At night, after the twins slept, she sat at the little table beside their beds and remembered her father. Thomas Fenwick had never spoken grandly about courage. Once, when a tenant's roof had failed and the owner refused to pay for repairs, he had spent half a day arguing on the tenant's behalf. Lydia had asked why he risked his position for people who could offer him nothing. 'Because I know what is happening,' he had answered. 'Once you know, choosing not to act is a choice as well.' The words returned to her now with uncomfortable force.
On the third evening, she found Edmund trying to tie a strip of cloth to the nursery window handle. He explained that it was a signal, the kind sailors used when their ships were in trouble. If Papa saw it from the road, he might understand. Lydia helped him fold the cloth and tucked it away so Cecily would not find it. Later, when the boys were asleep, she stood by the glass looking over the dark trees. She had begun to understand that waiting for rescue could become another way of abandoning them.