men. On rainy afternoons he sat near the nursery fire while Lydia conducted lessons, often with a book in his lap that remained unopened. Sometimes she asked a question about geography or a historical passage, and Arthur found himself caught in discussions that lasted well beyond the hour he had intended to spare.
The first disagreement between them concerned punishment. Oliver pushed another child during a visit from a neighboring family, then declared the other boy had begun the quarrel. Arthur, embarrassed before the guests, told him sharply that he would be confined to his room for the evening. Lydia requested a private word and suggested that Oliver be required to apologize and repair the damage he had caused rather than be shut away alone. Arthur bristled, because he had already spoken and did not relish being contradicted. Then he remembered how fear had made Oliver lie in the morning room, and he reconsidered. He spoke with his son, heard the entire story, and decided on an apology that Oliver could understand and mean.
Afterward Arthur thanked Lydia for challenging him. She replied that it was her duty to guide the boys, not to flatter their father. He laughed, surprised into genuine amusement, and she smiled back before recalling herself. It was a small exchange, but it changed the ease between them. Arthur began to ask her opinion about books, tutors, exercise, and even the arrangements for the children's visit to their aunt. In time he found himself looking forward to her answers as much as to the questions that prompted them.
Lydia remained careful. She knew the household listened whenever Arthur lingered in the nursery. A duke might consult a governess about lessons without scandal, but too much warmth could be turned against the woman who depended on his favor. She therefore kept their conversations in shared rooms and generally in the presence of Mrs. Pritchard or the children. She was grateful for the trust he placed in her and wary of how easily gratitude could become an obligation to overlook her own needs.
The new position brought other challenges. A visiting tutor objected to receiving instructions from a woman who had once been a maid. Lydia met him with her written authority and a careful account of the boys' progress. When he persisted, Arthur supported her decision to seek another teacher. Several older servants found the change in her station difficult to accept, and Lydia herself felt uneasy when the housekeeper insisted she use a different dining room. She tried to honor the friendships she had formed belowstairs without pretending nothing had changed. Her former companions appreciated the effort, although some distance remained.
One afternoon she received a letter from her mother, who now lived with a cousin near Bath. The handwriting was unsteady, but the news was good: the roof had been repaired, and the extra money Lydia sent would permit the purchase of coal before winter. Lydia read the letter twice beside the