The proposal was the first document she brought to Arthur upon returning. He read it closely and asked questions about cost, supervision, and whether the scholarships should favor girls whose fathers had worked on the estate. Lydia argued for some places to be open to families from neighboring villages as well. Arthur agreed to seek advice from Miss Elwood and the parish schoolmistress rather than making promises on sentiment alone. Their discussion lasted most of an afternoon, and when it ended, Lydia saw that he had treated her plan as an idea worth improving, not a favor to be bestowed.
That evening Arthur walked the garden after the boys went to bed. He had intended to tell Lydia that her absence had shown him how much he depended upon her, but he paused before speaking. Dependence was not the same thing as love, and he feared confusing the two. He had once chosen Cecily because he wanted someone to relieve him of responsibility; he would not make a second woman bear the weight of his needs under a more flattering name. When he finally spoke to Lydia in midsummer, he meant to offer a partnership that allowed her work and her judgment to remain her own.
Her mother visited in late spring and stayed in a modest guest room Arthur insisted was available without ceremony. Mrs. Fenwick was a clear-eyed woman with worn hands and a habit of noticing more than she spoke. After a week at Oakhaven she asked Lydia whether the duke treated her kindly. Lydia answered yes. Her mother asked whether kindness made Lydia feel free to disagree. Lydia thought of their discussions about the children's schooling and answered yes again, though more slowly. 'That matters,' her mother said. 'But remember that gratitude is not a marriage, and admiration is not freedom. A good man will want you to remain yourself.'
Those words stayed with Lydia through the summer. She continued teaching the boys, reading in the gardens, and talking with Arthur when their paths crossed. She began keeping a small journal, not of romantic hopes but of decisions she might make if she were entirely free: further study, a school for girls of modest means, perhaps a home where her mother could live without worrying about every shilling. Imagining these possibilities helped her recognize that her life had value beyond the service she gave to the Ashcombe family. Oddly enough, that knowledge made her affection for Arthur steadier, because it was less entangled with fear.
In June an opportunity arose for Lydia to visit an academy near Bath that trained young women as governesses. A former acquaintance of Marianne's had heard of Lydia's work and wished to discuss a possible role in developing a curriculum. Arthur received the invitation and handed it to Lydia unopened, saying the choice was hers. She looked startled. The journey would remove her from the boys for nearly a fortnight, and she knew Arthur depended upon her. He arranged temporary lessons with Mrs. Pritchard and encouraged her to go. She accepted, grateful and uneasy in equal measure.