The first scream reached the Duke of Bellmere before his carriage had crossed the last bend of the avenue. It was a child's scream, thin and desperate, and it came from the direction of the morning room, where no child ought to have been at that hour. Arthur Ashcombe put his hand against the carriage door before the wheels stopped turning. Rain had darkened the gravel and soaked the trees of Oakhaven Abbey, yet he hardly noticed the cold as he stepped down, leaving his startled coachman to manage the horses. Three days early, with mud to his knees and exhaustion behind his eyes, Arthur had come home expecting to surprise his sons.

He heard a second cry as he hurried across the entrance hall. This time he knew the voice: Oliver, the elder twin by seven minutes, who rarely cried when he was hurt and always cried when someone frightened his brother. Arthur's heart began to pound with a violence no parliamentary debate or mine disaster had ever inspired. A footman started to speak, but Arthur passed him without slowing. The door to the morning room stood open, and beyond it an ivory gown lay torn on the carpet like a collapsed sail. Near the fireplace, Lady Cecily Harcourt was holding a heavy iron poker above the heads of two small boys.
Between them and the poker stood Lydia Fenwick, the nursery maid. Her plain gray dress was smeared with ash; her hands were outstretched; her face showed the particular fear of someone who understood the danger perfectly and refused to yield. Oliver and his twin, Edmund, clung to her skirts. Cecily's mouth was moving, and as Arthur reached the threshold he heard the words clearly enough to remember them for the rest of his life. 'Move, girl, or you shall regret ever having been born.'
'No,' Lydia answered. Her voice shook, but she held her place. 'I will not let you touch them.'
Arthur had made many mistakes in the three years since his wife died. For one dreadful instant, he saw every one of them collected in that room. He had mistaken elegance for kindness, obedience for affection, and a woman's public tenderness toward his children for the love those children deserved in private. He had placed his household beneath Cecily's authority and then ridden away. The realization was so complete that his anger arrived strangely quiet.
'She will not move, Cecily,' he said.
The poker fell from Cecily's hand and struck the hearthstone. The twins looked toward the door. 'Papa?' Edmund whispered, as though he scarcely trusted his own eyes.
Arthur knelt, regardless of the wet mud on his boots. Both boys rushed toward him. He gathered them close and felt their small bodies trembling against his coat, while Lydia remained standing a few feet away, uncertain whether she had saved the children or merely bought them another kind of trouble. On the carpet lay an expensive gown, torn across the bodice and stained with soot. Arthur could understand an accident. What he could not understand, and could never excuse, was a grown woman raising an iron bar against a child.