"You still favor your left shoulder," Caleb said. Gideon glanced at him. "And you still announce a punch before you throw it." The words were ordinary enough that Caleb nearly smiled. Instead he turned away, feeling suddenly the years between them. Gideon watched him for a while, then said quietly, "I remember what happened in that barn. I was there."
"Pa ran past me to get to you," Caleb answered, his voice rising. "No," Gideon said. "He ran toward you. That is what I remember." Caleb spun, one step too fast, and Gideon blocked his arm before the blow had a chance to land. Neither tried another. The struggle lasted less than a breath and left them both ashamed.
"He died because trouble followed you," Caleb said. Gideon released his sleeve. "Maybe. Trouble followed me before I knew your name." He looked at the frozen creek. "My first father was hanged while a sheriff stood by and watched. I was nine years old, and the town decided I would grow into his crimes. Your mother was the first person who looked at me and saw a child instead."
Caleb's anger faltered. Eleanor had never told him that much about Gideon's childhood, only that some stories belonged to the people who had lived them. "Why didn't you tell me?" he asked. Gideon looked at him without accusation. "Because I didn't want you to think I was asking for pity. And because Ma said a person's beginnings don't decide where he belongs."
They camped that night a mile off the main road. The wind moved through the cottonwoods with a dry, papery sound, and Caleb cooked beans in a blackened pot while Gideon patched a loose stitch in Scout's bridle. For a while the brothers spoke only of practical things: the distance to Cedar Hollow, the possible routes in winter, the number of armed men in town. Then Caleb asked whether Gideon still used Mercer's name.
"Not in a long time," Gideon answered. "I took Vale after a man who died saving my life. I stopped using Pa's name because I didn't think I'd earned it." Caleb watched the fire. "Ma wrote me once that you'd come home when you figured out you had." Gideon gave a tired smile. "Then I guess Sunday is my chance to prove her right."
"We are not riding in shooting," Caleb said at once. "A dozen armed men in a town full of women and children. The first mistake could get Ma killed." Gideon nodded. "Good. I've been trying to think of a way to keep you from making the first mistake." Caleb shook his head, but this time he almost laughed. It was the first moment since they met when the air between them felt anything like familiar.
Friday morning found Cedar Hollow wrapped in cloud and bitter cold. Wade Cutter tested the gallows with a sack of grain, watching the platform drop cleanly beneath its weight. He hauled the sack up and tested it again, because Rourke preferred fear administered with professional care. Behind the church, two men dug a grave between the crosses of Jasper Flint and Elias Kline. One grave was all that had been ordered; no one knew whether the company expected to need another.