Wainwright brought the case to Cedar Hollow and read through it with Caleb before allowing anyone else to touch the documents. Gideon stood by the window while the captain explained that evidence would need to be authenticated and witnesses found, but the records were substantial enough to justify immediate arrests. The presence of duplicate deeds suggested that Sloane's company had deliberately misrepresented what families had signed. The supposed winter tax had no county authorization at all. It was extortion backed by hired violence and the threat of illegal executions.
"What happens to the land?" Eleanor asked. The captain met her eyes respectfully. "The court will have to determine which transfers were obtained under duress, ma'am. We can't undo them by sunrise. But we can secure the documents and keep the company from selling another acre while the matter is heard." She nodded, accepting a difficult answer because it was at least an honest one.
Clara gave Wainwright Eleanor's tin box, and Celia Flint provided Jasper's original complaint. Thomas Dyer brought receipts for assessments he had paid during the summer, and other families began producing documents they had kept hidden under floorboards or in flour bins. Ben Larkin agreed to testify about orders Rourke had given, including the plan to move the hanging once the Rangers were summoned. Martin supplied copies of the payments he had received and admitted the threats used to secure his cooperation. No single piece of evidence proved everything, but together they formed a record that Sloane's ledger could not explain away.
Orson Pike was arrested at the post office the next morning. He tried to burn the contents of a locked drawer when the Rangers entered, but the stove was too cold to catch the papers quickly. Among the letters were copies of correspondence sent to state officials, including Elias Kline's complaint and a petition from the blacksmith's wife. Celia held the unopened envelope bearing her husband's handwriting for a long time. Then she handed it to the captain and asked him to make certain the court saw it.
The arrests did not give Cedar Hollow back its dead, and the first weeks afterward were more difficult than anyone had imagined. Rourke's hired men had been paid from the same company money that funded the feed store's credit accounts and the county road repairs. With the business frozen, merchants wondered how they would survive the spring. Farmers whose deeds had been transferred under threat still needed seed and livestock. Even families that had never signed anything had lost months of work to fear and suspicion.
Eleanor returned home to a kitchen that smelled of cold ashes and apples left too long in a bowl. The house seemed smaller than she remembered and full of shadows where memories had been waiting. Caleb carried in firewood while Gideon checked the roof for storm damage, and within an hour the two men were arguing over the best way to fix a loose chimney bracket. Eleanor sat by the stove listening, a cup of tea warming her fingers. She had dreamed of their voices together for twelve years, and now she discovered that the ordinary irritation of brothers was almost unbearably sweet.