Gideon watched through the rifle sights, helpless in the way he had been helpless twelve years earlier. He could see Eleanor's face, and he could see the flicker of fear she could no longer conceal. For a moment he almost took the shot he knew was too dangerous, simply because waiting hurt. Then he remembered Caleb's words on the creek: a dozen armed men, a town full of children, and no life that could be saved by recklessness.
He lowered the muzzle slightly and called down from the ridge. "Cyrus Rourke! You want the man who came after you? I'm here. Let her go and you can face me instead." The voice carried over the square. Men searched the rocks above them, but Gideon's position remained concealed by the shadows and snow.
"Show yourself," Rourke shouted. Gideon rose just enough for the red poncho to be visible. The crowd murmured, and Ben Larkin took an involuntary step backward. He knew the story now and understood that the man on the ridge had chosen not to shoot Rourke when he could have. That realization made Wade Cutter's threats seem less like strength than desperation.
"My father used to tell a story about a man in red," Ben said aloud. Wade snapped at him to be quiet. Ben looked toward the fallen shotgun, then at Eleanor. He thought of the money he had sent to his mother and how little of it could undo what he had helped do here. Slowly he unbuckled his holster and set it in the snow. "I'm done," he said. "I won't shoot anybody for you again."
One of Rourke's older men raised his pistol toward Ben. Caleb fired into the post beside him, splintering the wood inches from his hand. "Leave that boy alone," he ordered. The gunman hesitated, then lowered his weapon. Two more men did the same, not because they had become good people in an instant, but because the certainty that had held Rourke's power together was failing.
Rourke saw it happening and pulled Eleanor tighter. "Cowards," he spat. "Every one of you." He tried to drag her toward the back of the platform where a narrow stair led behind the courthouse. Eleanor braced her foot against the rail, refusing to walk. She was not strong enough to overpower him, but she could slow him long enough to make him look away from the pistol. Martin stepped in, seized Rourke's wrist, and forced the muzzle toward the sky.
The revolver discharged with a terrible crack. The shot struck the gallows beam, sending a shower of splinters across the platform. Eleanor stumbled free, and Caleb rushed from behind the trough. Gideon fired once more, striking Rourke in the shoulder as the man tried to turn the pistol toward Martin. Rourke fell against the railing and dropped his gun into the snow below.
Wade Cutter reached for the dropped weapon. Before his fingers closed around it, Ben Larkin caught his sleeve and pulled him backward. Caleb crossed the last yards and kicked the pistol out of reach. "Hands where I can see them," he commanded, putting himself between Wade and the crowd. Wade looked from Caleb to Gideon's red poncho and made the first sensible decision of his career. He raised both hands.