A smaller gunman stepped forward from the shade of the stable. His name was Ben Larkin, and he was young enough that his cheeks had not entirely lost their boyish roundness. He had joined Rourke for the promise of wages he could send home to a sick mother in Missouri. The last months had made him increasingly sick at heart, but he had stayed because men who left Rourke without permission sometimes disappeared along the road. As Gideon turned, Ben's eyes fixed on the worn red cloth.
"I've heard about that poncho," Ben said. Gideon raised a brow. "It's old and it doesn't keep out much rain. Not much to hear." The young man looked less sure. Wade laughed and told him to stop listening to barroom stories. From the courthouse steps, Martin Bell watched the exchange with an expression that grew paler the longer he looked at Gideon.
Martin knew the stories, too. Years before he became sheriff, he had ridden cattle north from Laredo, and a man in a red poncho had helped him out of a fight that should have killed him. Martin did not know that man's name, but he remembered a refusal to shoot an unarmed opponent and the way the red-clad rider had disappeared before anyone could thank him. Gideon passed without acknowledging him. That courtesy unsettled Martin more than a challenge would have.
The brothers took rooms above the boardinghouse under names that were technically their own but not the ones Rourke would expect. Gideon signed Vale; Caleb signed Mercer, saying he had been named after an uncle. The boardinghouse keeper, Mrs. Agnes Ford, looked from one face to the other and quietly asked whether they needed two rooms or one. "Two," Caleb answered instantly. Gideon muttered, "Best make them on opposite ends of the hall."
Agnes had been friends with Eleanor since the widow first arrived in the valley. She had washed the sheets used to cover Jasper Flint's body and delivered food to Elias Kline's wife after the second hanging. Her own son had gone to Albuquerque rather than sign his property over to Sloane, and she lived with the fear of a letter saying he had met trouble on the road. She served the strangers stew, watched them avoid looking at each other, and noticed how Caleb reached for his water glass with the same long fingers as Samuel Mercer. She did not speak of her suspicion until the dishes were cleared.
"Your mother told us to watch for red and green," she whispered while refilling Gideon's cup. The brothers froze. Agnes inclined her head toward the back door. "The sheriff's daughters will come after dark. Use the alley behind the stable, and do not take a lamp. Rourke searches homes and shops, but nobody thinks to search Martin Bell's own barn."
Caleb caught her wrist gently before she moved away. "Is she alive?" Agnes's eyes softened. "Yes. She still scolds the sheriff every time he brings her food. I'd say she's alive enough for all of us." Gideon exhaled, and the tension in his shoulders eased for the first time since he had opened Eleanor's letter. Agnes looked at the red poncho and smiled sadly. "I had wondered whether you were real. Your mother never doubted it."