Outlaws Were Hanging the Old Widow Over $70 — Then She Wrote Two Letters

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Samuel Mercer had not been immediately welcoming. He had looked at the thin, wary child, listened to Eleanor explain, and gone outside to feed the horses. The next morning he came in with a small pair of boots and a wooden whistle he had carved overnight. Gideon remembered that more clearly than the day the adoption papers were signed. Samuel had never asked the boy to forget his first father, and Gideon had never forgotten the kindness of that restraint.

Caleb had been born years after Gideon joined the family. His first words were clumsy versions of Gideon's name, and he followed his older brother everywhere, dragging a toy gun through the barnyard and insisting he would become a lawman. Gideon taught him to ride, to find north from the stars, and to keep his hand away from a revolver unless he understood exactly what it could do. They had been brothers before either knew the word for the blood that separated them. That was what made the silence afterward so difficult to bear.

The fight that killed Samuel began with a cattle thief named Rafe Colter, a man Gideon had been hired to track. Caleb, still wearing a deputy's star, had gone into a stable to make an arrest, and Gideon had ridden behind him because he feared Colter would not surrender. Samuel followed when he heard there were armed men near the supply barn where Eleanor had come to trade. Colter aimed at Caleb from a loft; Samuel ran between them. The bullet struck Samuel just below the shoulder, and he died before the doctor reached the yard.

There were facts Gideon and Caleb agreed on, and facts each remembered differently. Gideon had seen the gunman first but had failed to shout soon enough. Caleb had rushed into the barn without waiting for help. Samuel's decision to shield his younger son was his own, made in the few seconds that remained to him. At the burial, however, Caleb's grief needed someone to blame, and Gideon's grief was already practiced at accepting blame. Words were said that neither could forget.

On Thursday, Caleb arrived at Antelope Crossing an hour before sundown. A stand of cottonwoods bordered the creek, their branches black against the winter sky. He watered his horse and waited with his hat pulled low. He told himself that if Gideon did not come, he would ride on alone and get their mother out. He did not know whether he would feel relieved or betrayed.

The red poncho appeared between the trees when the sun touched the western hills. Gideon stopped his horse twenty yards away and took Caleb in without moving his face. "Twelve years," he said. "You've got Pa's eyes more than I remember." Caleb's hand tightened around the reins. "Don't call me little brother," he said. "You gave up that right at the grave."

Gideon dismounted before answering. "Ma asked for both of us," he said. "I'm here." Caleb got down from the buckskin and faced him across the frozen grass. "I'm here for her. Don't mistake that for anything else." Gideon nodded, as if the distinction were fair enough, and began unpacking the horses. They had almost finished the work before Caleb spoke again.

News in the same category

Outlaws Were Hanging the Old Widow Over $70 — Then She Wrote Two Letters

30 Part