The man looked at Clara, then at the gun lying in the mud, and understood that violence would not improve his position. "Old charcoal yard," he muttered. "North of the creek road. They changed it this morning. Vale's people know somebody has the book." The stranger tied both men to the wagon wheel with their own rope and asked a passing teamster to fetch a constable. The teamster stared at the prisoners and disappeared toward Main Street. Clara waited until they were out of earshot to ask whether the law could be trusted. "Not all of it," the stranger said. "But we need the town to see what happened. Otherwise Vale can tell any story he wants."
They returned to Mrs. Bellamy's house with mud on their clothes and fresh pain in Clara's wrist. The widow met them at the kitchen door, brought them inside, and closed the shutters. She set a basin on the table, and Clara washed her hands while trying not to shake. The ledger slipped from its hidden seam as she changed the dressing. Mrs. Bellamy saw a name near the middle of the open page and stopped breathing for a moment. "Where did you get that?" she whispered.
Clara turned the book. "My father's accounts. Why?"
The widow touched a line with one finger. "Lillian Bellamy. That's my niece." She sat down without looking for a chair. "She went to work at a hotel outside Lead last spring. We received one letter. Then a man came and said she had gone to Denver with a husband. She had no husband, and she would have told me if she did." Mrs. Bellamy pressed her palm against her mouth. Clara looked at the entry beside Lillian's name: a date, a cash payment, and an abbreviated route. It was a transaction, but now it was also a girl who had grown up calling somebody Aunt Ruth.
They spent the next hour asking Mrs. Bellamy everything she remembered. Lillian had been nineteen, liked horses, and wrote long letters full of small observations. She had a pale scar on her chin from falling through ice when she was eight. She had planned to save enough money to open a laundry with her aunt. The widow produced the last letter, worn at the creases from repeated reading. Its handwriting matched the signature on an employment contract she had saved. The stranger listened, then asked whether Mrs. Bellamy was willing to tell her story to other people. "I have been telling it for months," she said. "No one wanted to hear."
"They'll hear now," Clara told her.
Pike came after supper with two freight drivers, Samuel Orr and a fellow named Jacob Ames, a former cavalry sergeant named Elias Dawson, and a miner named Peter Novak whose sister had vanished on the road to Custer City. Each had a reason to distrust Vale. Orr had carried a young woman to a boardinghouse and been ordered not to ask questions about why she never emerged. Ames had been paid to transport locked crates that shifted when the wagon stopped. Dawson had once refused an offer to work as an armed escort for a route that did not appear on any legal freight schedule. Novak had heard nothing from his sister since she accepted a cook's position through Vale's agents.