Despite the progress, Clara could not forget Spearfish Creek. At night she pictured the charred beams of home and wondered whether her father's body still lay beneath them. She feared going back and feared never returning. The stranger noticed her reluctance whenever anyone mentioned the road north. On the fourth morning he saddled two horses and asked whether she wanted company. "For what?" she asked, though she knew. "To find what can still be found," he said. Clara packed the ledger in a secure case and left a copy with Pike. Mrs. Bellamy hugged her at the door, careful of the tender wrists.
They rode out under a cold blue sky. The country beyond the town looked unchanged despite everything that had happened. Pine stood on the ridges, brown grass flattened beneath the first frosts, and a hawk made slow circles above an empty pasture. Clara remembered riding the same road in summer with her father, arguing about whether the mare needed new shoes and promising to buy him a pair of proper winter gloves. Such small memories had become treasures she did not know how to carry. The stranger let her set their pace. He understood that moving toward grief was different from moving toward danger.
At a creek crossing they stopped to water the horses. Clara sat on a log and asked what he believed would happen to Rourke. "If the freight men reached him in time, he'll face a hearing," the stranger answered. "If they didn't, he chose a lonely end for himself." Clara looked at the running water. "I thought I'd feel better leaving him alive." "Do you regret it?" "No. I just expected to feel sure." He took off his hat and ran a hand through his gray hair. "Doing the right thing doesn't always make a person feel easy. Sometimes it only makes the next morning possible."
Farther north they met a rancher named Henry Bell, who had known her father for years. He recognized Clara from a distance and came down the trail bareheaded, his face changing as he approached. "We thought you'd died," he said. He dismounted and held her shoulders gently. His own house stood two miles downstream, and he had seen the smoke on the night of the attack. By the time he reached the Whitfield property, the roof was falling and the men who had started the fire were gone. He had searched the ruins at first light with his sons. The information he had to give her was painful, but it was not uncertain.
"We buried your father on the hill behind the orchard," Bell told her. "Near your mother's stone, where he always said he wanted to rest. We put a marker there. I didn't know if you'd ever come to see it."
Clara lowered her eyes. It was the answer she had feared, and it arrived with an almost unbearable kindness. The stranger stepped away to tend the horses. Bell explained that her father had been found near the cellar entrance, where he must have tried to hold back the men long enough for her to escape. He had not died instantly, according to what Bell could tell, but there was no way to know whether he had heard the house collapse. Clara listened without interrupting. She wanted the facts, even the ones that hurt. They were part of her father's last story, and she would not let Rourke take them from her.