A murmur moved through the crowd. Vale's guards exchanged a look. The stranger dismounted slowly, with enough stiffness to remind everyone that he was not a young man eager for another fight. He kept both hands visible. Clara climbed down from her mare and helped Mary and Rose leave the wagon. Elizabeth followed with her head high. Dr. Mercer came through the crowd when she saw the women, and Mrs. Bellamy brought blankets. For the first time, the people listening to Vale could see exactly what kind of freight he had been describing.
"Ask these women where they were going," Clara said.
Vale shook his head with practiced sympathy. "They've been frightened. I wouldn't put much faith in what they say before a doctor examines them."
Elizabeth turned toward him. "You had better listen to me while I have the courage to speak." Her voice carried farther than she expected. "I was promised work in a laundry. Men with guns took me from the road and held me in a locked house. This morning I was tied in a wagon bound for your warehouse. I heard your name at the farmhouse. I heard it again when your driver took his orders."
Vale's pleasant expression narrowed. "An unfortunate misunderstanding between contractors."
"Then tell us why your contracts list people as cargo," Clara said. She drew out the ledger and held it above her shoulder. "My father kept these records. He was killed because he refused to destroy them. The names are here. So are the payments."
At the edge of the crowd, Peter Novak pushed forward, having recognized a name on the handbill Pike was passing from person to person. "My sister was on one of those lists," he shouted. "You told us she left town. Who did you sell her to?" Others called out as well. Mrs. Bellamy stood beside him and named Lillian. Men who had once lowered their voices around Vale were speaking in the open, their anger sharpened by the discovery that each had been made to feel alone.
Vale beckoned his guards. "Take the ledger. We can have it inspected by men qualified to read business records."
One stepped toward Clara. The stranger moved between them, not drawing his weapon. "No one touches her," he said. The guard looked uncertain. He was paid to frighten miners and push debtors out of offices, not to start a shooting match in front of a hundred witnesses. Vale's other guard took his pistol from its holster. The stranger seized his wrist before the weapon was fully raised and forced it against the doorpost. The revolver clattered to the steps. Dawson and Orr moved up behind the guard, rifles pointed at the ground but ready. Nobody fired.
"You see what he's doing?" Vale shouted. "Violence in the street!"
"I see it," said a miner beside the freight wagon. "I see your man pulling first."
The remark traveled through the crowd, repeated by people who had watched the guard's hand. The stranger released the man as soon as Dawson had him secured. Vale backed toward the warehouse door. Clara stepped into his path. They were close enough that she could see the small gold chain running from his waistcoat to his watch. He smelled of expensive soap. It enraged her that a man who had traded human lives could be so carefully dressed, as though there were no dirt in the world he needed to worry about.