Lillian came home after Christmas. A wagon brought her through an afternoon of falling snow, and Ruth met it in the street before the driver had finished drawing the reins. They embraced so fiercely that the people outside the boarding house turned away to give them privacy. Clara watched from the doorway. Lillian was thinner than her photograph, and she looked over her shoulder whenever a man raised his voice, but she had her aunt's eyes. That night Ruth made chicken pie, her niece's favorite meal, and invited everyone who had helped with the search. There were too many chairs for the kitchen, and the younger people sat on the stairs with their plates.
Lillian did not tell her story at supper. Nobody asked her to. She listened while Daniel described a runaway horse that had nearly overturned a wagon, and once she smiled at something Mrs. Bellamy said about a stubborn stove. Later, when most of the guests had gone, she asked Clara whether she could help find other women. "Not tomorrow," Clara told her. "Tomorrow you're going to sleep late and let your aunt fuss over you. When you're ready, you can decide what you want to do next." Lillian looked relieved. It was not the answer she had expected from somebody the town had begun calling courageous.
The hearing proceedings began in earnest after winter weather eased enough for witnesses to travel safely. Clara rode with Pike and Dawson to give evidence before a court handling charges that could be supported by the ledger and sworn testimony. She had expected the room to look like a place where truth was obvious. Instead it held wooden benches, clerks with ink-stained fingers, impatient lawyers, and people who were tired from long journeys. Vale appeared in a dark coat and looked almost respectable. Rourke's right arm remained stiff, and the sight of him brought back the ravine so suddenly that Clara had to steady her breathing before entering.
Bennett had prepared her for the questions. She must say what she saw, distinguish that from what others told her, and never pretend certainty she did not possess. On the stand, Clara described the fire, the hidden seam, the men who took her, the chain on the rock, and the ledger her father had entrusted to her. Vale's attorney attempted to suggest she had misunderstood business terminology and had relied upon a violent stranger to create an accusation. Clara listened until he finished. Then she answered that the women who had been found bound in the wagon could speak for themselves, and the accounts matched the statements of the men who transported them.
The attorney turned to her father's death. "You did not personally witness your father take his last breath, did you?" he asked. Clara felt every eye in the room settle on her. "No," she said. "I saw him fall when the men came through the door. Mr. Bell and his sons found him after the fire. I will not claim to have seen what I didn't see." The lawyer seemed prepared for a more emotional answer. Bennett's clerk looked up from his notes. Clara went on, "But I saw who took me away. I saw the ledger. And I am here to tell the court exactly what happened to me."