"How's the brace?" "Still there." "How's the wing?" "Still crooked." "Then my work here is complete." She sat on the edge of the gazebo steps while volunteers moved around her. "Grandpa?" "Hmm?" "Did you ever think the Children's Tree was ugly?" "Of course." Emma laughed. "Seriously." "I am serious. Some years it looked like a craft store exploded in a windstorm." "Then why did you like it?"
George was quiet for a moment. "Because liking something and approving of its appearance are not the same operation." "That's a very Caroline sentence." "Don't insult me on Christmas Eve." She smiled. George continued. "When your mother was little, she made me a tie rack in shop class. Crooked piece of pine. Three pegs. Horrible finish. Couldn't hold more than two ties without tilting."
"Do you still have it?" "Of course." "Why?" "Because your mother made it. That is the whole explanation. We get into trouble when we think everything important needs a second explanation that sounds impressive to strangers." Emma looked at the two trees again. "The big tree is important too," she said. "Sure." "Mrs. Whitmore did a lot of work on it."
"Also true." "So why did she stop understanding the other one?" George sighed softly. "Probably because people praise you for what you're good at until you start thinking your strength is the answer to every question. Caroline is good at making things polished. That's useful. It just isn't useful everywhere." Emma thought about that. "What am I good at?" "Watching." "Mom said that too." "Then for once your mother is correct."
"Is that dangerous?" "Everything is dangerous if you decide it makes you right all the time." Emma let that settle. George asked whether Caroline had hung Abby's angel. Emma told him she had. She described the red scarf, the low branch, the way Caroline adjusted the angel once and then stopped herself. "That's something," George said. "Mom says I don't have to forgive her." "Your mother is right. Again. Troubling evening."
"Do you think I should?" "Forgiveness isn't a board resolution. Nobody votes it into effect." "That's not an answer." "It's the best one I've got. You can stop being angry before you trust someone. You can understand someone without excusing them. You can accept an apology and still remember why rules changed. Don't force all those things to happen at once just because stories like tidy endings."
Emma looked at the repaired cardinal. "You really hate tidy endings." "I built cabinets for forty years. I like tidy joints. Endings are different." They said goodnight. Emma stayed seated for another minute with the phone in her lap. A little wind moved across the green. Abby's paper angel fluttered. The red cardinal turned once and settled again. Nearby, the professional tree remained almost motionless because its ornaments had been wired and clipped to resist exactly that kind of movement.