HOA Karen Ripped Decorations Off the Kids' Christmas Tree — Then an 11-Year-Old Girl Confronted Her

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"That's a dramatic word." "The wing broke." "Wings do that." "Wooden ones don't grow back." "Good point." She waited for him to say they could make another. He did not. "Bring it Sunday," he said. "We'll look at it." "Are we going to fix it?" "We're going to look at it. Those are different verbs." On Monday morning, the board secretary found the resolution. It had been adopted in 2016. The title was Children's Holiday Tree Tradition.

Daniel sent the PDF to the board first, then to the families involved. Jennifer opened it on her laptop after dinner with Emma and Mark standing behind her. The wording was not vague. The purpose of the Children's Tree is to provide a space where neighborhood children may display individual handmade ornaments without aesthetic uniformity requirements, subject only to reasonable safety and weather-resistance standards. Emma read the sentence twice.

"Without aesthetic uniformity requirements," Mark repeated. Jennifer scrolled farther down. "Motion proposed by Caroline Whitmore." Emma thought she had misheard. "What?" Jennifer turned the laptop toward her. There it was. Caroline Whitmore. Motion seconded by another resident. Approved six to zero. Attached to the minutes was a summary of the discussion. Ten years earlier, a professional decorator had removed a handmade angel made by Caroline's then-nine-year-old daughter because it did not match the official tree. Caroline had objected so strongly that the board created a separate Children's Tree and formalized its purpose. A quoted comment from Caroline appeared in the minutes. Children should have one tree where nobody tells them their Christmas is the wrong color.

Emma sat down slowly. Noah, who had been coloring at the other end of the table, looked up. "Did she say that?" Jennifer nodded. "Then why did she take mine?" Nobody had a good answer.

The 2016 resolution changed the argument, but it did not end it. That surprised Emma. She had imagined, in the simple way children sometimes imagine rules working, that finding the exact sentence would make everyone stop talking. Caroline had written the rule. The rule protected the tree. Caroline had violated the rule. Therefore the argument should be finished.

Adults, Emma discovered, could continue an argument long after the facts had become uncomfortable. Caroline did not deny the resolution. Instead, she said circumstances had changed. The Children's Tree had grown larger over the years. More residents participated. Materials were more varied. The common green was being photographed for a public feature. Weather standards had improved. The committee had an obligation, she wrote, to interpret traditions in light of current conditions.

Daniel answered that interpreting a tradition did not include erasing its stated purpose. A board member named Ruth Delgado asked whether any later policy had repealed the phrase about aesthetic uniformity. The management company found none. Another board member, Tom Pierce, who generally disliked HOA conflict and believed almost every dispute could be solved by everybody being less emotional, said, "I think the resolution is pretty clear."

News in the same category

HOA Karen Ripped Decorations Off the Kids' Christmas Tree — Then an 11-Year-Old Girl Confronted Her

40 Part