Caroline adjusted it once. Stopped. And did not adjust it again. Emma wanted to ask if she was sorry for the rest of it. She wanted to ask whether Abby would come home next year, whether Caroline hated the main tree now, whether losing the chair position hurt, whether she finally understood. She asked none of those things. Caroline touched the edge of the paper angel. "She made this at our dining room table. Glitter was in the carpet for years." Emma smiled faintly. "Noah has glitter in his ears sometimes."
"That sounds difficult." "Mostly for the rest of us." Caroline almost smiled. Then she stepped away from the tree. "Merry Christmas, Emma." "Merry Christmas." Caroline walked home before the luminary crowd arrived. There was no hug. No applause. No photograph of reconciliation.
The angel stayed on the tree.
At five o'clock, the first luminaries flickered on along the walking path. From the entrance monument to the pond, white paper bags glowed in two uneven rows. The light arches over Hawthorne Drive came alive one section at a time. Families stepped out of houses in winter coats carrying travel mugs, strollers, mittens, and children already overexcited by the idea of staying outside after dark. The Christmas Train Depot switched on its tiny red signal. The North Pole post office opened its mailbox. The Grinch garage inflated a green figure that immediately leaned sideways in the wind and had to be tied to a porch column by three laughing teenagers.
Evergreen Ridge did not look like a magazine spread anymore. It looked better. At least Emma thought so. The professional tree still commanded the green from a distance. Twenty feet of white lights, champagne ribbon, silver ornaments, and carefully spaced gold stars made it glow like something from a hotel lobby or a department-store window. People stopped to take pictures in front of it. Couples posed. Families tried to make toddlers look at cameras. Older children pretended not to enjoy standing under it until they saw the photos.
The Children's Tree attracted a different kind of crowd. People did not pose in front of it as much as they leaned close. Parents pointed. Teenagers searched for things they had made years before. Children explained objects no adult could identify. A woman Emma barely knew found a faded ornament with her son's preschool photo inside a plastic lid and laughed so loudly that three people turned around.
"He has a beard now," she said to no one in particular. "Look at that face." A man beside her answered, "That's what time does. Very disrespectful." The tree became a conversation people had to walk around rather than a backdrop they stood in front of. Emma sat beside George near the gazebo with two cups of cocoa between them. His hands trembled slightly when he lifted his cup, so she held the cardboard sleeve while he drank. "Don't tell your mother," he said. "Tell her what?" "That I'm cold. She'll wrap me in blankets until I look upholstered."