Yet people called the neighborhood beautiful because all of it existed together. Emma wondered why that had been easier to accept on private lawns than on one shared tree. At the pond, they found Mrs. Patterson, one of the residents who had written online that the Children's Tree looked messy. She was walking with her grandson.
Noah, who had no idea which adults had written which comments, proudly told her, "My reindeer is back." Mrs. Patterson looked at Emma, then at Noah. "I'm glad." "It has four eyes now." "I heard." "Because it survived." "So I also heard." Her grandson asked if they could go see it. Mrs. Patterson hesitated only a fraction before saying yes.
As they walked away, she said quietly to Emma, "For what it's worth, I was wrong to call the tree junky." Emma had no prepared response. Mrs. Patterson continued, "I still think some of those ornaments are hideous." Emma laughed before she could stop herself. "But apparently that's not the same question." "No," Emma said. "It's not." That conversation mattered because it separated two things the neighborhood had spent weeks mixing together: taste and permission. Mrs. Patterson did not have to love the purple dinosaur. Caroline did not have to like the red cardinal. Daniel did not have to believe Noah's reindeer had improved after growing a fourth eye.
The Children's Tree did not require consensus about beauty. It required room. Back at the green, George had acquired three cookies, though Mark claimed he had only handed him one. Emma suspected Janice Porter was involved. "I saw the angel," George said when she returned. Emma sat beside him. "Mrs. Whitmore hung it." "Did she?" "Yeah."
"Good." "That's all?" "What else do you want? Fireworks?" Emma leaned back against the bench. "I don't know." George looked at the crowd. "People expect endings to announce themselves. Most of them don't." "That's annoying." "Life has poor structure." She looked toward Caroline's red scarf near the far path. "Do you think she's sorry?" "For what part?" "All of it." George took a bite of cookie and chewed before answering. "Probably not all in the same way. People can regret hurting somebody and still think their original idea was right. They can miss power and understand they misused it. They can be embarrassed and sorry at the same time. Human beings are inconvenient like that."
"So what do I do?" "About her?" Emma nodded. "Nothing tonight. It's Christmas Eve." "That's not very philosophical." "Sometimes wisdom is knowing when to drink cocoa." Emma took his advice. She spent the next hour not thinking about Caroline. She helped Sophie relight a battery candle. She watched Malik's father lose a mitten and accuse Malik, only to discover it in his own pocket. She stood with Noah under the light arches while he tried to catch snowflakes on his tongue even though no snow was falling. She took a photo with her parents in front of the official tree and another with George beside the Children's Tree.