The luminary lights reflected in the dark water. Children moved along the path behind them carrying battery candles. For several minutes, Daniel stood beside her without speaking. "Ruth says the extra storage key is still with you," he said eventually. Caroline reached into her coat pocket and handed him a key ring. "Thank you." "There are three vendor contacts in my phone that aren't in the shared file yet. I'll send them tomorrow." "After Christmas." "It will take two minutes."
Daniel looked at her. "After Christmas." She almost argued. Then she nodded. "The green looks good," she said. Daniel glanced at the crowds. "It does." "The main tree ribbon is sagging on the west side." "I hadn't noticed." "I know." For a second, the old Caroline surfaced in the dryness of the comment. Daniel smiled despite himself. She looked toward the Children's Tree. "You could have reminded me about the resolution earlier." "I didn't remember it either."
"I wrote it." "Yes." "That's embarrassing." "Yes." Caroline gave him a sharp look. "You're not going to make this easier for me, are you?" "You were chair for eleven years. You never made anything easier for me." Unexpectedly, she laughed. It did not repair what had happened. It did not restore her position. It did not convert the board hearing into a misunderstanding. It was simply the first normal exchange they had shared since Ornament Night.
"Abby sent the angel," Caroline said. "I saw." "Emma brought it to my house." "I know." "She shouldn't have had to do that." Daniel looked at her. "No." Caroline nodded slowly. "I spent years telling people that traditions mattered because they gave families something stable. Then I decided the tradition mattered less than the way it photographed."
"You also spent years making a lot of those traditions possible." "That sounds like the beginning of an excuse." "It isn't. It's the reason this got complicated. If you'd been useless, we'd have stopped you sooner." Caroline looked almost offended, then understood. Daniel continued. "The board relied on you because you were competent. You started treating reliance as authority. We let you. That part is ours. What you did with it is yours."
"Fair." The word came reluctantly. They stood watching the crowd. A toddler ran through a row of luminaries and knocked over two bags. His father apologized to nobody in particular and set them upright. A group of teenagers took selfies beside the official tree. Noah's voice floated across the lawn as he explained his four-eyed reindeer to yet another unwilling listener.
Caroline said, "This would have driven me crazy last year." "What?" "All of it. Bags crooked. Children touching displays. People standing where they aren't supposed to." Daniel looked around. "Anything actually unsafe?" Caroline studied the scene. "No." "Then maybe that's enough for tonight." She did not answer, but she stayed where she was instead of walking over to straighten anything. At eight-fifteen, Mark told Emma that George needed to leave. The cold had finally become too much. His face looked pale under the gazebo lights, and his hands had stiffened despite the gloves. Emma's first reaction was disappointment. She had imagined him staying through the end of the luminary walk, maybe until the final crowd thinned.