Mark answered the electrical point because he was an electrician. "The strand was battery powered. No line voltage crossed the table." The management representative confirmed the event plan had been approved and no safety inspection had ordered the tree cleared. A volunteer testified that Caroline had removed items based on color before any discussion of weather safety. Aaron Bell's written statement confirmed he had not asked for the Children's Tree to be altered for photographs.
Then the board read the 2016 resolution into the record. The room changed when Daniel reached the quote. "Children should have one tree where nobody tells them their Christmas is the wrong color." He looked at Caroline. "Those are your words." Caroline stared at the table. "Yes." "Do you disagree with them now?" The answer took several seconds. "I think standards matter."
"That wasn't the question." Caroline looked up. "No. I don't disagree with them." "Then why did you remove ornaments because they didn't match your design?" Caroline's composure slipped for the first time. "Because the entire green had become something I was responsible for presenting. Every year people expect it to improve. Every year there are more lights, more events, more photographs, more complaints if something looks neglected. I spent months making that display coherent, and then the one piece everyone could see from every angle looked like no one had thought about it at all."
Ruth said, "Someone had thought about it. Children had." Caroline rubbed one hand over the other. "You know what I mean." Daniel's response was quiet. "Yes. I think we do." He did not embarrass her by reading Abby's statement aloud. He summarized it instead: the original resolution had come from Caroline's defense of her own daughter's handmade ornament after a decorator rejected it for aesthetic reasons. That history mattered because it showed the resolution was not accidental wording. It was the purpose. Caroline closed her folder.
For the first time, she looked older than sixty. Then Sophie Lee's mother described the physical contact. She did not exaggerate it. Caroline had not thrown Sophie or injured her seriously. She had gripped the child's upper arm and moved her aside after the child continued gathering ornaments. Sophie had told her to stop. The issue was not catastrophic harm. It was that a committee chair had treated a child as an obstacle during a dispute she herself had escalated.
Caroline said she had been trying to prevent Sophie from stepping on broken pieces. Sophie’s mother answered, "Then you say, 'There's broken clay under your knee.' You don't grab her because you're angry." The room went quiet again. Finally Daniel asked Emma whether she wanted to speak. Her mouth went dry. She had practiced three sentences with George. They vanished. Jennifer squeezed her hand once and let go. Emma stood with the clear box containing the cardinal.